Chapter 4: Dangerous Game

Ryan’s truck finally pulled up outside the lake house. The snowstorm had slowed down a bit, but heavy snow still covered everything. My heart was beating so fast I thought it would explode. Ethan and I had just finished fucking again. His thick cum was still leaking down my thighs. I quickly pulled on my clothes and tried to look normal.

“Stay calm, baby,” Ethan whispered. He kissed me hard one last time. “Act normal. But know that your pussy is still full of my cum while you talk to your brother.”

I nodded, my face red. The guilt was strong, but the thrill was stronger.

The door opened and Ryan walked in, shaking snow off his jacket. He looked tired but happy to see us. “Damn, that storm was crazy! You two okay? I was worried.”

Ethan smiled like nothing happened. “We’re good, man. Ava was safe the whole time.”

Ryan hugged me tight. “Thanks for looking after her, bro. I owe you one.”

I felt Ethan’s eyes on me. His warm cum was deep inside me. It made my pussy throb. I smiled at my brother. “Yeah… Ethan took really good care of me.”

We sat by the fire. Ryan talked about the bad roads and how he almost got stuck. Ethan nodded and acted normal, but under the blanket his hand was on my thigh. His fingers slowly moved higher, teasing my cum-soaked panties.

I tried not to moan. Ryan was sitting right there.

When Ryan went to the kitchen to make coffee, Ethan pulled me close and whispered in my ear, “I’m so hard again. Your brother being here makes me want to fuck you more.”

“Ethan, stop,” I whispered, but my hand brushed against his hard cock through his pants.

Ryan came back. We talked for a while, but the tension was crazy. Every time Ryan looked away, Ethan touched me — squeezing my ass, brushing my breast, or sliding a finger along my wet panties.

Later, Ryan said he was tired and went to take a shower. The moment the bathroom door closed, Ethan grabbed me.

“We have ten minutes,” he growled. He pushed me against the wall in the living room. “Pull your pants down. Now.”

I was scared but so turned on. I quickly lowered my pants. Ethan did the same. His thick cock sprang out, hard and ready.

He lifted one of my legs and pushed inside me in one thrust. “Fuck, you’re still so wet and full of my cum.”

He fucked me fast and hard. His hand covered my mouth to keep me quiet. The sound of the shower running made it even hotter.

“Take that cock while your brother is in the next room,” he whispered. “Such a naughty little sister.”

I moaned against his hand. He pounded me deep. My breasts bounced. The risk made everything feel ten times better.

“Cum for me, Ava,” he ordered.

I came hard, shaking. My pussy squeezed his cock. Ethan groaned quietly and filled me with another hot load.

We quickly fixed our clothes just as the shower stopped.

Ryan came out. “You two are quiet. Everything alright?”

“Yeah,” Ethan said, voice calm. “Just relaxing.”

But under the blanket, Ethan’s fingers were back inside my cum-filled pussy, slowly fucking me while we sat with my brother.

The day went on like that. Small touches. Stolen kisses in the kitchen when Ryan went to check the generator. Every moment was dangerous and exciting.

At night, Ryan said he would sleep on the couch. Ethan and I had to share the bed in the other room.

As soon as the lights were off, Ethan pulled me close under the covers. “I’m going to fuck you slow and quiet while your brother sleeps ten feet away,” he whispered.

He slid into me from behind. Spooning position. His hand covered my mouth again. He moved slow but deep. Every thrust felt amazing.

“You’re mine, Ava,” he breathed in my ear. “Even with Ryan here, this pussy belongs to me.”

I came quietly, biting his hand. Ethan filled me again.

But in the middle of the night, Ryan woke up. “Hey, you guys awake? I heard some noises.”

My heart stopped. Ethan was still inside me.

Ethan answered calmly, “Just the wind, man. Go back to sleep.”

Ryan went back to the couch.

Ethan started fucking me again, harder this time. “That was close. But you got wetter when he almost caught us, didn’t you?”

“Yes…” I admitted, moaning softly.

He fucked me until we both came again.

The next morning, the snowstorm picked up again. Ryan said the roads were bad once more. He might have to stay longer.

Ethan looked at me with dark eyes full of lust. “Looks like the game continues, baby.”