LOGINTony stood at the bar, filling a mug of beer. He topped it off and sent it sliding down the counter, then leaned back, his eyes fixed on the door. Matt came up behind him, his voice low. "She’s not coming through that door anytime soon."
"Who?"
"Whatever, dude. You know exactly who I’m talking about." Tony tried to move around him, but Matt wouldn’t budge. "Dude, don’t act like you don’t know."
"Gemma? She’s just Kyle’s kid sister. That is it," Tony replied.
"You are so full of it," Matt said, throwing a bar rag over his shoulder. "Tell me this: if she went to school closer, where would you be? At Kyle’s—and not because of Kyle."
Tony remained silent, shifting his gaze back to the rows of bottles behind the bar. He didn't know what to say to Matt because it was no secret how he felt; everyone could see it plainly. Admitting it out loud, however, was a hurdle he wasn't ready to clear, even to himself.
"Would you knock it off? There’s nothing between me and Gemma." Tony’s phone buzzed with a text. Good night, Tony.
Tony grinned. Good night, Shortcake. That was all he needed—confirmation she was okay.
"You see that right there?" Matt asked, gesturing toward Tony's smile. "That is not the look of someone who is just checking up on his friend's sister." He laughed.
"Whatever." Tony shoved past him to make a drink for a customer at the far end of the bar.
"When was the last time you dated anyone?" Matt pressed. "Now be honest. I'm waiting."
Tony paused to think. He honestly couldn’t remember the last time he’d been on a real date. Was it a year ago? It had been just before he did the tattoo on Gemma’s shoulder. But Matt didn’t need to know that.
After closing up for the night and seeing Matt out, Tony headed upstairs to his apartment. He stripped down and collapsed into bed, falling asleep as soon as he hit the mattress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gemma was jolted awake by what felt like a caffeine-charged gremlin tearing through the room. Groggily checking her phone, she groaned, "Please tell me I didn't agree to live with someone who wakes up before the roosters".
The girl glanced up at Gemma, eyebrows raised. “Wouldn’t know,” she said. “Never heard a rooster in person before.” She went right back to digging through the box, bracelets clinking softly as she sifted deeper, only a messy ponytail visible. Suddenly she popped up, triumphant, holding a pair of sneakers over her head like she’d just won a prize.
“Found them!”
“Great news,” Gemma muttered, retreating under her blanket. After a second, she peeked out again. “Wait—what exactly did you find?”
“My running shoes.” The girl was already lacing them with quick, practiced movements. “I go jogging every morning. Best time to clear the mind.” She shot Gemma a grin. “And also the best time to meet eligible men.”
“At this hour, the eligible men are probably eligible serial killers,” Gemma said, finally sitting up. “So that’s a no for jogging.” She reached for her phone on the nightstand. “Besides, if you ever see me running, you better run faster—because something is definitely after me.”
The girl burst out laughing. “Fair enough.” She flashed a bright, easy smile. “Fredrika Jones. But everyone calls me Freddy.”
“Gemma Havley,” she replied, tucking her hair behind her ear. “And before ten a.m., I don’t care what anyone calls me.”
Freddy let out a friendly laugh. “Got it. New roomie is not a morning person.”
Gemma flopped back against the bed with a groan. “Not even a little bit.” A small smile tugged at her mouth.
“Okay,” Freddy said, already bouncing to her feet. “I’m gonna go for my jog, and if you help me tackle this disaster when I get back, I’ll show you all the good places to go. You know—the ones that don’t card.”
Gemma reached for her phone, then pointed toward the desk. “I’ll help if you bring back a mocha latte. There’s money right there.”
Freddy plucked the ten‑dollar bill off the desk and held it up. “Awfully trusting, aren’t you? Just handing me cash.”
“Nah,” Gemma said with a smirk. “I know where you live.”
Freddy laughed, delighted. “I think we’re gonna get along great, Gemma Havley.” She headed for the door, tugging her ponytail tighter. “I’ll be back in an hour.”
====================================================================
Gemma sat up and swung her legs over the edge of the mattress as she heard the door open upon Freddy’s return.
"Look at that, the room gremlin is up," Freddy noted.
Gemma collapsed back onto the bed. "No, it doesn't count; only my feet are up".
Laughing, Freddy offered her a supportive hand to help her sit back up and passed over a latte. "It's a beginning," she remarked. "The rest of you will wake up once the caffeine takes effect".
Freddy laughed, offering a hand to help Gemma sit up before handing over the latte. "It"s a start," she noted. "The rest of you will catch up once that caffeine kicks in."
Gemma took a cautious sip of the coffee and set it down on the nightstand. "I wouldn"t bet on it," she replied.
Freddy reached for a box and began the process of folding and hanging clothes. She glanced back at Gemma with a grin. "You gonna help?"
The pair managed to tuck away all of Freddy’s belongings within a few hours, their constant laughter and banter making it feel as though they had been friends for years. During the process, Freddy mentioned she hailed from a city just thirty minutes north of Bronson, while Gemma spoke of her upbringing in an Oklahoma town where everyone knew everyone else.
Once they were finally finished, Freddy turned to Gemma. “So, now you’re definitely going out with me tonight, right?”
Chase was standing just inches from her, his shadow falling completely over her, when the sudden, sharp rattle of a key in the deadbolt broke the silence.Instantly, Chase stepped back. The cold, predatory look vanished from his face, replaced in a split second by the polished, phony smile he used to charm everyone else on campus.The door swung open, and Freddy bustled in, wrestling an overstuffed duffel bag and a travel mug through the frame. She looked up, brushing a strand of hair out of her face, but her bright smile faltered the second she took in the room. The suffocating, heavy tension in the air was so thick it practically choked her.Freddy’s eyes darted between the two of them. She looked at Gemma, who was visibly rattled—pale, backed against the dresser, and trembling slightly—and then over to Chase, who stood entirely relaxed, playing the part of the picture-perfect, all-American male flawlessly.Freddy dropped her bag heavily onto the floor, her protective instincts imme
The rest of the drive passed in a suffocating silence. Gemma kept her eyes glued to the passenger window, watching the dark Colorado landscape blur past, hyper-aware of the locked doors and the steady rhythm of Chase’s breathing beside her.When he finally pulled into the parking lot of her dorm, Gemma reached for the handle before the car was even fully in park. "I can take my bag from here. Thank you for the ride.""Don't be ridiculous," Chase said, his voice smooth as he cut the engine. "I'm not letting you lug that all the way up to the third floor by yourself."He was out of the car and popping the trunk before she could argue.Gemma followed him into the building, her stomach tying itself into tighter and tighter knots with every step they took up the stairwell. He walked just a little too close behind her, his presence a heavy, looming weight.When they reached her door, she fumbled with her keys. Her hands were shaking so badly it took three tries to get the deadbolt to turn.
The air inside Denver International was chaotic and loud, but Gemma felt a strange sense of calm as she walked through the terminal. She had ignored three new texts from Chase since landing, but she didn't hesitate to pull up her contacts and hit Tony’s name.He answered on the first ring.“Wheels down?” Tony’s voice came through the speaker, instantly making the crowded, stressful airport fade away.“Safe and sound,” Gemma said, shifting her bag higher on her shoulder. “Though it is freezing here.”“Told you to steal another hoodie,” he teased softly. A beat of quiet affection passed between them over the line. “You got that Uber lined up yet?”“Getting ready to order it right now,” she promised, nearing the exit. “I'm just walking out to the pickup zone.”“Good. Text me when you get in the car, and text me the second you lock your dorm door.” She could practically hear the smile in his voice.“Ok I will. Bye, Tony.” Gemma laughedGemma hung up, a small smile playing on her lips. She
Soon, the house filled with laughter and conversation as Tony’s parents, Judith and Martin, arrived. Judith brought in deviled eggs, a salad, and a couple of trays of cupcakes. Dee shook her head. “You shouldn’t have brought so much, Judith.”“Nonsense,” Judith replied with a snort. “I know how my two guys eat—and you’ve got two just like mine.”They all gathered around the dining room table, passing food and mostly teasing Tony and Gemma—but also giving Kyle plenty of grief for losing the bets he’d made against his sister. But as dinner was winding down and the turkey had almost been picked clean, Gemma’s text message tone went off. She pulled her phone from her pocket, expecting a note from Freddy, but it was Chase:Mom is upset you couldn't be here for dinner. I told her there's plenty of time.When Gemma didn’t reply, another message came through:I can't wait to see you Sunday. I’m still picking you up from the airport, right?Gemma groaned quietly. She couldn’t—or rather, wouldn
“Yeah, you look more like—what is Barbie’s little sister’s name?” Kyle teased.Gemma reached over, grabbed the sprayer from the faucet, and gave him a quick squirt.“Hey, hey!” Dee called out, her hands on her hips. “You’re getting my freshly mopped floors all wet.” She took the sprayer from Gemma with a mock stern look.Kyle smirked, triumphant. “You got in trouble.”Gemma ignored him as she finished peeling the potatoes. “Hey, where’s Tony?” she asked Kyle.“Last time I saw him, he was sprawled across my couch sawing logs. You kept him up most of the night.”“I came in early,” she smirked.“Yeah, early as in me shutting down the bar and driving all the way home.”“It’s such a long drive, Kyle,” Gemma teased. “And you shut the bar down at one last night because of the holiday.”“I’m going to go get him up—if the rest of us have to be up, so does he.” Gemma washed her hands and dried them off. She headed toward the door, and Kyle shook his head at her.“Gotta get your fix again this m
No sooner had she lain down than her phone buzzed with a text message on the nightstand.Gemma rolled over, the warm feeling of Tony’s kisses instantly vanishing as she watched the screen light up.Goodnight, Gems. Hope you are enjoying your family. Can’t wait to see you when you get back.Gemma let out a weary groan, the sound muffled by her pillow. Just reading that nickname—the one he insisted on using no matter how many times she had told him not to—made her stomach queasy. Chase just wouldn’t take a hint.She stared at the glowing text, the shadow of Colorado creeping back into her mind. With a decisive motion, she flipped the phone face down back on the nightstand. She wasn’t going to let him ruin tonight. Pulling the blankets around her shoulders, she closed her eyes and focused on the quiet, familiar sounds of her family's house, forcing herself to think only of Tony.But she had just fallen asleep when her phone went off again, the sudden vibration jarring her awake. Grumblin
When they pulled into the drive at home, Tony got out and helped Gemma down. They stood for a moment, just looking at each other, before heading inside. Their mother was waiting at the door.Kyle grinned. “Look what I found walking down the road.”“Oh, Gemma, it’s so good to have you home,” her mom
Gemma had agreed to let Chase drive her to the airport Wednesday morning. When he pulled up to drop her off, he said, “I’d feel much better if I was going instead of just my shirt, but it’ll do. I’ll meet the family some other time.”“Okay, I’ll see you Sunday night,” she replied, already reaching
“You were good enough to meet my family in that getup you had on last night, and yet I’m not good enough to meet your family?” Chase challenged.Gemma met his gaze evenly. “If you feel that way, leave, Chase.” She’d finally come to a conclusion—this was done before it got any farther.Chase took a
The next morning, as Gemma lay in bed, her phone buzzed with a new text. She reached for it on the nightstand.Chase: Morning, Gems. How about having breakfast with me?Gemma groaned. “I just want to be lazy today. No Chase, no books, no anything. Just sleep. Sunday all day sleep.”Freddy laughed.







