What Are The Best Barnaby X Wally Fanfiction Stories To Read?

Barnaby and Wally are from 'Welcome Home,' right? That fandom's still growing, so pure crossovers aren't super common yet. My best luck has actually been on Tumblr or Twitter threads where writers do 'ficlet requests' or 'ship swaps'—you sometimes find someone who's mashed them up with characters from 'Over the Garden Wall' or 'Coraline' for that same creepy-cute aesthetic. I also check AO3 tags regularly. You gotta be a bit creative with search terms. Try filtering the 'Welcome Home' tag and then adding 'Crossover' or 'Fandom Fusion.' Sometimes people don't tag the secondary fandom perfectly. I once found a wild one where Barnaby was a detective in 'Psychonauts,' and Wally was a sentient stamp. The weirdest combos often come from writing prompts on Discord servers dedicated to horror-adjacent cartoons.

I'll be honest, I mostly stick to 'Tiger & Bunny' for the main canon, so my scope might be narrow. But from what I've seen in that corner of the fandom, the most popular take is a kind of speculative sci-fi. People lean into the android/machine angle, really getting into the mechanics of Fantoccio's existence and what that means for sentience and connection. It's less about traditional romance genres and more about existential questioning dressed up as a ship. I read one recently where the entire plot was Barnaby trying to repair Fantoccio after a major battle, and the emotional payoff wasn't a kiss, it was a single, flickering light in Fantoccio's eye unit. That hit differently than your usual fluff. Another angle I've noticed is casefic, which makes sense given their jobs. Stories framed around solving a mystery or taking down a villain, where their partnership is the central driving force. The relationship builds through action and reliance, not through internal monologues about feelings. It feels very true to the source material's vibe. I tend to skip the pure coffee-shop AUs for this pair; the dynamic just seems to work better when there's some kind of mission or mechanical problem to solve together.

Barnaby and Wally's fanfiction hinges on that inherent contrast—the bombastic versus the subdued. Authors love to dissect how Wally's quiet, observational nature actually grounds Barnaby's larger-than-life persona. I've read a few where Barnaby's entire comedy routine is performative armor, and Wally is the only one who sees through it, not by calling him out, but just by being a steady, non-judgmental presence. It flips the expected dynamic; the 'funny one' isn't always the one providing emotional support. That unspoken understanding gets a lot of play. Fics often have them communicating in glances or shared silences that speak volumes, which feels true to their 'best friends' canon status. The exploration isn't usually about romantic tension for me—it's about the deep comfort of a friendship where you don't have to perform. Some of the most touching ones are just slice-of-life: Barnaby trying to teach Wally a joke, Wally patiently listening to Barnaby's latest idea, that sort of thing. It's the stability of it all that gets me.

Barnaby x Wally stories tend to zero in on a specific kind of dynamic: the tension between performative cheer and quiet vulnerability. It's a built-in trope because their core personalities set it up. Barnaby's the outgoing entertainer, always 'on,' and writers love exploring what happens when that act drops. Is he secretly exhausted? Does he feel a pressure Wally just doesn't perceive? Wally's calm, methodical nature becomes a safe space for that unraveling. He's not demanding more energy; he's just there, steady. So many fics I've read hinge on Barnaby having a bad day, retreating, and Wally just... staying. Not with grand gestures, but by quietly making tea or sitting in companionable silence until Barnaby feels real again. That contrast between Barnaby's loud love and Wally's quiet devotion is the heart of most romance plots I come across. Another huge theme is the 'understanding beyond words' angle. Because Wally communicates so deliberately, fanfiction often gives him an almost supernatural ability to read Barnaby's real feelings behind the jokes. It flips the script on their public dynamic. The big, loud guy isn't the one who fills the silence; it's the quiet one who understands it. I've seen some amazing stories where Wally points out the specific micro-expressions Barnaby makes when he's genuinely happy versus when he's forcing it, and Barnaby is just floored that someone noticed. It creates this incredible intimacy that feels earned, not just shipped for the sake of it. Less common but really compelling are the fics that play with artistic synergy. Barnaby's comedy is a performance, and Wally's painting is a craft. Stories that have them collaborating—Barnaby inspiring a series of joyful, colorful paintings, or Wally helping Barnaby design a more visually cohesive stage persona—add a layer of partnership that goes beyond just emotional support. They become each other's muse, and the romance blooms in that creative shared space, which feels very true to their characters.

Hm, this is a fun one because 'Barnaby x Wally' from 'Welcome to Night Vale' has such a specific, weird energy that the tropes end up feeling unique. A huge one is probably 'Human Monstrosity' or 'The Flesh Is Weak' – exploring Wally's unsettling, possibly non-human or meat-puppet nature through Barnaby's cheerful obliviousness or deliberate acceptance. You get a lot of 'Cosmic Horror Coziness' too, where the terrifying existential dread of Night Vale is just background noise to their domestic life, like Barnaby grumbling about the dog park while Wally reports on the latest unspeakable horror with the same chipper tone. Another big trope is 'The Secret's Out,' but inverted. Instead of a dramatic confession, it's often about the community already knowing and not caring, or Wally revealing something horrifyingly intimate on air that Barnaby has to just roll with. There's also a niche for 'Role Reversal' where, in an AU, Barnaby becomes the voice of Night Vale and Wally is the one trying to maintain a semblance of normalcy, which highlights how their dynamic is built on their established roles. The tropes here feel less about romantic milestones and more about navigating a shared reality that's fundamentally broken, which is why they're so compelling.

So I've been neck-deep in the Super Crooks fandom for years now, and the Barnaby/Wally dynamic is this weirdly perfect engine for fanfic. It's all built on that classic 'opposites attract' but with so many layers. You've got Barnaby, the celebrity cynic who's seen it all, and Wally, the genuine, almost naive powerhouse. The most common conflict I see isn't just 'will they/won't they'—it's a complete clash of worldviews. Fics often dig into the tension between image and reality. Barnaby is hyper-aware of public perception, of the brand. Getting involved with a teammate, especially someone as open as Wally, is a PR nightmare waiting to happen. A lot of plots revolve around him trying to manage that, to keep things secret, which of course clashes with Wally's straightforward nature. Wally doesn't get why you'd hide something good. Then there's the emotional baggage. Barnaby's past, his family legacy, his jadedness—it all builds walls. Wally's conflict is simpler but just as potent: how do you love someone who seems determined to push you away for your own 'good'? I've read some incredible fics where the central conflict is Wally slowly dismantling Barnaby's defenses not with grand gestures, but with persistent, quiet kindness that Barnaby just can't rationalize away. The best plots make you feel the ache of two people who fit together perfectly logically, but emotionally they're speaking different languages until they learn to translate. The real juicy stuff often comes after they get together, too. How does a relationship even function when one of you can level a city block by accident? The conflict shifts from 'getting together' to 'staying together' amidst super-powered crises and the sheer weirdness of their lives. That's where the fandom really shines, inventing new problems only they could have.

I stumbled into the Barnaby/Wally tag after reading everything else in the Welcome Home fandom, and what keeps me coming back is how the dynamic gets used to examine different kinds of strength. Barnaby’s whole thing is this performative, loud confidence, right? But the fics that dig deepest flip it—they show him using humor as a shield, deflecting real vulnerability with a joke until Wally, who’s already operating on this weirdly literal and earnest frequency, just doesn’t get the deflection. He takes the joke at face value or asks a quiet follow-up question that dismantles the whole routine. That contrast becomes a tool for growth. You’ll see Barnaby having to learn new emotional language, something quieter and more direct, because his usual toolkit fails. Meanwhile, Wally’s often written as someone learning emotional nuance from the ground up, so Barnaby’s journey mirrors his own but from the opposite direction. It’s less about fixing each other and more about building a new, shared understanding that neither could access alone. The best ones make their partnership feel like a safe workshop for trying out feelings, with all the awkward pauses and missteps that come with it. Sometimes it’s played for gentle comedy, other times it’s deeply poignant, especially in AUs where they’re both human or facing a genuine crisis. The growth isn’t signaled by grand declarations, but by small shifts—Barnaby telling a joke that’s just for Wally’s understanding, not an audience’s laugh, or Wally initiating physical comfort in his own deliberate way.

Barnaby and Wally? That's a deep cut from 'Welcome to Night Vale' fandom, isn't it? You're looking for that specific weirdness where Cecil's boyfriend meets the puppet from a kids' show. It's not a huge pairing, so you have to get creative. Honestly, your best shot is on Archive of Our Own—their tagging system is a lifesaver. Use the 'Crossover' tag combined with 'Welcome to Night Vale' and maybe 'Cecil Palmer/Barnaby' or just 'Barnaby'. Sort by date updated; the really old stuff might be orphaned or deleted from other sites. Don't ignore Tumblr, either. The search function there is terrible, but a lot of writers post snippets or link to their AO3 from there. Try searching "Night Vale Barnaby Wally" and then just scroll. It's a digital archaeology project sometimes. You might also find remnants on Dreamwidth communities or super old LiveJournal sites, but a lot of those links are dead. I found a good one once by following a rec list on a fan's personal blog. It's a pairing that thrives on vibes more than volume, so when you find a story, it's usually someone who really gets the bizarre, tender heart of both characters.