What Loot Should Players Get After Defeating A Beholder?

If your party just felled a beholder, congratulations — that fight deserves something memorable. I like to think about loot in three layers: immediate practical spoils, weird unique trinkets tied to the creature's nature, and long-term story hooks. For coin and gems, go classic: a pile of coin, a few art objects, and some polished gems that the beholder fancied. Add a handful of uncommon potions and scrolls (maybe a couple of scrolls with illusion and divination spells — the sort of magic a paranoid eye tyrant would keep handy). I often steal a page from 'Dungeons & Dragons' loot tables but twist it: swap one random rare item for something beholder-themed to keep players surprised.

Then come the eye bits, which are where the fun is. I love offering harvested eye rays as single-use reagents — preserved ocular glands that, when used, let a caster or wielder emulate one of the eye rays (force one creature to be petrified, charm, or emit a cone of disintegration-ish energy) but only for a short burst. Another cool drop is an artefact I call the 'Gazer Shard' — a crystalline piece of the central eye that can be attuned and grants a selectable eye effect a few times per day, with a risk: if you overuse it, it lashes back with paranoia effects or temporary madness. There should also be unique trinkets: a stitched beholder-skin hood that grants resistance to psychic effects but makes stealth checks harder because the wearer keeps glancing suspiciously, or a pair of spectacles made from a lesser eye that give truesight for a minute but slowly reveal horrifying whispers.

Finally, I layer in story hooks. The beholder's lair might hide maps to a rival's territory, notes describing mutated servitors (perfect for future encounters), or letters from an obsessed collector willing to pay big for the central eye. I once let my players find a ledger detailing bribes and deals — they sold it to a noble, which unlocked a whole urban political arc. Mechanically, balance is key: one or two rares/very rares at most for a mid-to-high-level party, a handful of consumables and a unique beholder item that grows in power if the players pursue a crafting or corruption story. Let the loot feel dangerous and tempting — that's the real reward in these fights for me.