Why Does 'Making It So' Have Mixed Reviews?

2026-03-18 20:16:43
180
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Start Test
Write Answer
Ask Question

2 Answers

Isaiah
Isaiah
Favorite read: Maybe Wrong, Maybe Right
Contributor Librarian
Patrick Stewart's memoir 'Making It So' is one of those books that really splits the room, and I totally get why. Some folks went in expecting a deep dive into his iconic roles—Captain Picard, Professor X—and were disappointed when it wasn’t just a behind-the-scenes tell-all. Instead, it’s more introspective, focusing on his personal journey, from his working-class roots to his struggles with self-doubt. I actually loved that aspect because it humanized him in a way interviews never could. But yeah, if you’re craving juicy 'Star Trek' anecdotes, it’s sparse. The pacing’s uneven too; his early life chapters are richer than the later career stuff, which feels rushed. And his writing style? Polished but distant—like he’s keeping you at arm’s length, which might not vibe with readers wanting warmth.

Then there’s the tone. Some reviews call it 'self-indulgent,' especially when he dwells on his theater work (which, admittedly, I skimmed). But others, like me, appreciated his honesty about fame’s loneliness. It’s a memoir that refuses to pander, and that’s brave—but also why it’s polarizing. Plus, the audiobook’s golden; his voice could narrate a grocery list and I’d listen. Still, it’s no surprise the book’s divisive: it’s not the nostalgic romp many hoped for, but a quieter, messier reflection on art and identity.
2026-03-21 02:04:14
11
Vanessa
Vanessa
Favorite read: Mixed Feelings
Active Reader Data Analyst
The mixed reviews for 'Making It So' kinda make sense when you consider how wildly different people’s expectations were. Hardcore 'Star Trek' fans might’ve wanted a treasure trove of set stories or production drama, but Stewart’s more focused on his Shakespearean roots and personal growth. It’s like ordering a burger and getting a gourmet salad—still good, just not what you craved. Some sections drag (his childhood chapters are oddly more vivid than his Hollywood peak), and his prose can be overly formal. But when he opens up about imposter syndrome or aging, it’s raw and relatable. That duality—part distant, part vulnerable—is why reactions are all over the map.
2026-03-24 23:22:00
7
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

Why does 'What If It’s True' have mixed reviews?

3 Answers2026-03-19 19:53:01
I picked up 'What If It’s True' expecting a mind-bending blend of speculative fiction and emotional depth, but I can totally see why opinions are split. The premise is brilliant—what if the fantastical elements we dismiss as fiction were actually real? But the execution feels uneven. Some chapters hit like a freight train, especially the ones delving into existential dread and human connection. Others, though, drag with clunky dialogue or pacing that kills the momentum. Another thing that divides readers is the tone. It swings wildly between poetic introspection and almost pulpy action, which can be jarring if you’re not prepared. Fans of literary subtlety might groan at the louder moments, while those craving adrenaline could find the quieter sections tedious. Personally, I adored the risks it took, even if not all of them landed. It’s the kind of book that lingers in your head, flaws and all, sparking debates long after the last page.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status