Local indie bookstores shelve this in ‘Sports Romance’ or sometimes ‘LGBTQ+ Fiction’—the bi rep in this one’s casual but well done. Found a signed copy at a con last year with a doodle of a hockey stick heart. The sequel’s teased in the acknowledgments, but no release date yet. Fingers crossed!
Man, 'Pucking the Wrong Side' is one of those hockey romances that sneaks up on you! I stumbled upon it while deep-diving into sports romance recs on a niche book forum. The author blends enemies-to-lovers tension with legit hockey jargon—like, you can tell they’ve either played or binge-watched too many games. The ebook’s on Kindle Unlimited, but I also found snippets on Goodreads from readers who highlighted the best chirps (the MC’s trash talk is chef’s kiss).
If you’re into audiobooks, the narrator nails the gruff goalie voice so hard I replayed his angry rants for fun. Some Tumblr blogs even dissect the penalty-box scenes frame by frame—there’s a whole meta about whether the love interest’s team jersey colors were intentional symbolism. Random, but I live for that deep-cut fandom energy.
Funny story: I borrowed this from a friend who underlined all the spicy parts in neon pink (very subtle). The ebook’s got a weird glitch where Chapter 12 repeats twice, but the comments section on Scribd turned it into a meme (‘bonus angst loop’). If you’re into merch, the author’s Etsy sells matching ‘Team Wrong Side’ puck coasters that my cat keeps stealing.
Oh! I literally just saw this title trending on #BookTok last week. It’s part of a whole wave of hockey rom-coms where the grumpy/sunshine dynamic hits different. You can grab it on Amazon, but heads-up—the paperback cover’s way prettier in person (glossy finish, icy blue lettering). I DMed the author once, and they linked me to a Wattpad draft of deleted scenes that’s low-key better than the epilogue. Pro tip: check Libby if your library has it; mine had zero waitlist for once!
Reddit’s r/romancebooks has a mega-thread debating ‘Pucking the Wrong Side’ versus similar titles like ‘Off the Ice.’ Someone archived a Google Doc with trigger warnings and steam ratings—super handy if you need to avoid specific tropes. The subplot about the MC’s rivalry with his brother’s team lives rent-free in my head now.
2026-06-23 07:00:30
13
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Claimed By My Ex's Rival Hockey Captain
Red butterfly
10
17.1K
When Bailey Carter walked in on her boyfriend tangled in bed with someone else, she swore she was done with love, and with hockey players.
Now, she is back in Michigan, working nights just to pay her grandmother’s hospital bills, trying to stitch her life back together one piece at a time.
Then he walks in.Orion Hayes—the arrogant, infuriating captain of Michigan’s hockey team, and her ex’s biggest rival.
He is cocky, ruthless and too damn gorgeous for his own good.
When he saves her at a club being bullied, he offers her a deal she can’t refuse—pretend to be his girlfriend to get his family off his back, and he’ll make sure her grandmother gets the best care money can buy.
But what starts as a fake relationship soon blurs into something dangerously real.
Under the swagger and smirk, Orion isn’t who she thought he was.And the more he pulls her into his world, the harder it gets to remember why she should stay away.
Her heart’s already been broken by one hockey player.Falling for another, especially her ex’s rival, might just be the biggest mistake of her life.
“I want you to touch me… right now. I’ll show that scumbag ex I’m good at sex too.”
Those were the last words Emily remembered saying before she woke up naked in the hockey captain’s bed — with her brother’s best friend staring back at her.
One drunken night.
One reckless mistake.
One positive pregnancy test that ruined everything.
Emily is a talented painter who just caught her boyfriend cheating.
Alex is the campus’s arrogant, playboy hockey captain who never does commitment.
Now they’re stuck together by an unplanned baby, crushing guilt, and a sizzling attraction that refuses to die.
He says he doesn’t do responsibility.
She says she won’t abort their child.
But as Emily’s paintbrushes capture feelings she’s terrified to name and Alex starts showing up at her dorm with midnight cravings and soft kisses, one thing becomes dangerously clear:
This hockey captain might just be hers… accidentally forever.
On the ice they are bitter rivals, but off the ice they can’t keep their hands off each other. Kael, the dominant alpha and coach’s son, has always clashed with Riven, the defiant omega who refuses to submit. When an explodes into raw, angry sex, neither of them expects it to become an addiction.
Now they risk everything sneaking around locker rooms and late-night practices, fighting on the ice while giving in to each other in the dark. What started as hate has turned into something far more dangerous, and neither alpha nor omega is willing to stop.
“Top or bottom?” Ethan's timid voice echoed in the motel room, and Kane scoffed.
“Suck me off first and I'll tell you,” Kane replied and seductively licked his lips.
“What makes you think I’d suck you? How about you kneel for me?” Ethan spat with a grimace, trying to sound unbothered even though he knew he had a lot at stake.
A low, husky chuckle slipped from Kane's lips, and the room fell into a strange silence, their breathing and the soft wind the only sounds between them. Suddenly, Kane wrapped his arms around Ethan's back, pulling him close as his hand slid down to grip him firmly. "Let’s do this."
******
Canada's top hockey star, Ethan Harrison, has it all, except control over his own heart. When his secret obsession with the United States’s star player, Kane Hau Alexander, is discovered, Kane doesn’t expose him; instead, he takes control and vows to claim him.
Rivals on ice, lovers in secret, their forbidden connection must overcome, boundaries, trust, and desire. But with jealous families, manipulative fiancées, and public scrutiny closing in, can their secret survive the ultimate game?
Alex’s life is a wild whirlwind at this rich hockey school. He’s a poor scholarship kid, but he’s killer on the ice.
Damien, the hot, cruel team captain, hates him — but can’t stop touching him while claiming he's not gay.
He slams Alex hard into the boards and whispers dirty words that make Alex’s body burn with heat and shame.
Then Lila, Damien’s crazy childhood friend, wants Alex for herself. She has dangerous secrets that can destroy him if he says no.
But Jax arrives — a kind, sexy hockey star who truly cares. He wants to protect Alex and make him his.
Now Alex is trapped between hate, obsession, and desire. One wrong move and he loses everything.
This steamy MM hockey romance is full of hot hate-to-love tension, dirty obsession, and a love triangle that will leave you aching.
“Admit it,” He growls, slamming my back against the wall, his body caging me in. “You like it when I piss you off.”
My breath catches as our bodies collide, heat and hatred sparking between us. I hate Dorian Hayes with every fibre of my being...so why can't I pull away?
For Noah Carter, hockey isn’t just a game–it’s an escape. The golden boy captain with a killer smile and a secret he can’t afford to slip, Noah’s carefully crafted lie is falling apart with every practice and every time he locks eyes with HIM.
HIM.
Dorian Hayes is fire on the ice with only one mission--Make it to the NHL. But there’s one person he never expected to see when he got in Bridgewater to play for the Artic-Blades.
Noah Fucking Carter.
The one person he hates with everything inside him. Cue in a plan to destroy everything Noah stands for.
But every time their bodies collide on the ice, Dorian can’t deny the pull. It’s infuriating, maddening…and addictive.
He doesn’t want to want Noah, but when their rivalry shifts from Icy stares to scalding touches, Dorian is forced to confront a truth he’s spent years skating away from: sometimes, the person you hate the most is the only one who truly sees you.
Man, that moment in the story where he picks the wrong side? It’s such a gut punch, but it makes so much sense when you think about it. The character was always driven by emotion, not logic—like when he ignored his mentor’s warnings earlier because he was too busy chasing glory. It’s foreshadowed in small details, like his impulsive bets or how he dismisses allies who disagree with him. The wrong choice isn’t just a plot twist; it’s the culmination of his flaws.
And honestly, that’s what makes it satisfying. Stories where characters fail because they stay true to themselves hit harder than random misfortune. Remember how 'The Last of Us Part II' handled Ellie’s revenge spiral? Same energy. The tragedy feels earned, and you almost want to yell at the screen, 'I told you!' But that’s the beauty of it—we love messy, human mistakes.
I've always been fascinated by how seemingly small choices in stories spiral into massive consequences, and picking the 'wrong' side is one of those deliciously messy tropes. Take 'Attack on Titan'—Eren’s early alliance with the Survey Corps felt righteous, but his later shift to the 'enemy' side tore the fandom apart. It wasn’t just about betrayal; it forced viewers to question who the real villains were. The narrative tension skyrocketed because suddenly, the moral ground wasn’t stable anymore.
In 'The Last of Us Part II,' Abby’s perspective flips the entire story on its head. Playing as her after she kills Joel? Brutal. But that’s the point. The game forces you to live with the 'wrong' choice, making you grapple with empathy you didn’t want to feel. It’s not just about plot twists—it’s about how those twists redefine the stakes. When a character picks the losing side or the morally dubious path, it’s rarely just a misstep; it’s a narrative detonator.
Ever since I got into 'The Witcher' games, I've been obsessed with choices that flip outcomes entirely. Picking the 'wrong side' isn't just about losing—it's about collateral damage. Like in 'The Walking Dead' game, where siding with Kenny over Jane led to that brutal fight. The suffering isn't just yours; it ripples to NPCs, relationships, even entire in-game communities. I replayed 'Detroit: Become Human' three times just to see how Markus' rebellion vs. pacifism altered Detroit's fate. The most gut-wrenching part? Innocent bystanders pay the price when you misjudge a faction's motives.
And let's not forget 'Mass Effect'—the genophage decision haunted me. Choosing to sabotage the cure might've stabilized the galaxy, but hearing the krogan's despair? Oof. Games like these make 'wrong sides' feel less like mistakes and more like moral quicksand. Even in lighter stuff like 'Fire Emblem', getting a unit killed because you underestimated an enemy's range? That's a different kind of regret.
The first time I watched that scene unfold, my jaw practically hit the floor. The way the camera lingers on his stick just grazing the wrong side of the puck—it’s such a tiny moment, but it changes everything. I love how the director frames it like a slow-motion car crash; you can almost hear the audience collectively gasping. The beauty of it is how it subverts expectations without feeling cheap. It’s not some explosive betrayal or grand gesture—just a quiet, human mistake with massive consequences.
What really gets me is how it mirrors his character arc. He’s spent the whole season trying to prove he’s not a screw-up, and then bam, the universe throws this curveball. It’s brutal in the best way. The aftermath scenes where he’s replaying it in his head? Chef’s kiss. Makes you wonder how often we’re all one split-second decision away from disaster.