Hmm, never really thought about how it happens. I just absorb the recommendations by osmosis, I guess. My reading list is basically a reflection of whatever r/Fantasy has hyped this month.
It’s a mix of genuine admiration and community in-jokes. 'Malazan' is a great example—part of its status comes from the endless 'just keep reading, it all comes together' comments, which have become a rite of passage. The book's reputation is intertwined with a specific Reddit culture around it, which amplifies its perceived importance beyond its actual readership numbers.
Sometimes it's the memes. 'The bonehunters' , 'I am a stick', 'nice bird, asshole'—these inside jokes from various series serve as constant, low-level advertising. They keep a book present in the community's mind even when it's not the direct topic of discussion. This ambient presence contributes to a feeling of ubiquity, which translates to 'greatness'.
The whole concept of 'all-time greats' on Reddit is heavily skewed toward modern, post-2000 epic fantasy. You’ll see Tolkien and maybe Le Guin as the obligatory old guard, but the list quickly fills with contemporary doorstoppers. This isn't necessarily wrong, but it reflects the demographic of Reddit's user base—readers who grew up with Jordan, Martin, and Sanderson. Classic sword-and-sorcery or older weird fiction often gets overlooked unless a dedicated niche subreddit pushes for it. So Reddit’s canon is really 'Reddit’s favorite fantasy from the last few decades,' which is a useful but incomplete snapshot.
Through exhaustive list-making. Reddit loves lists. 'Top 25 Fantasy Series of All Time' posts generate thousands of comments comparing and arguing. The aggregate of all these lists, created by users with different tastes, creates a blurred-average picture of the greats. Books that appear consistently across many different users' personal lists are the ones that earn the title. It’s crowdsourced canon formation.
2026-07-18 09:42:18
2
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Classic Faery Tales Rewritten For Adults Only
CityKim
0
4.9K
Seven Classic Faery Tales are given a very adult makeover.
You are entering a world of myth, magic, and Immortals.
Throw in the humans for the added spice of erotica and violence.
Mix together and you have dark adult faery tales ........
Do not read if easily offended!
Ten thousand years have past since the Megalos machi (great battle) between the kind and the remnants of The Level World. The kind have long been proved extinct and the world has moved on into a new age.
However deep in the Ignere forest they awake, they breed, they learn to fight, growing by the thousands waiting for the birth of their prince.
A golden .
Heir to the throne.
At his birth the nations will fall. No one could stand against him..well that's until he is taken and led far away from this world to ours.
Here he discovers he is the most powerful being in the universe..however he is at the mercy of one thing.
A human.
His mate.
book 1 in the Azian prince of dragons series - (currently editing)
Legora, the largest capital city in the world. Once one of nine, now there are four. We had lost five cities in the great calamity. Creatures from god knows where poured in from a tear in the earth. A dimensional tear in space and time the scientists called it, but really who the fuck knows? All I know is they were bigger, stronger, looked nothing like us and they outnumbered us hundred to one.
An overwhelming amount of refugees flooded the other cities, telling tall tales of heroes rising and taking on four to six creatures at a time. they fought them off while the rest escaped. Delusions, false hope, call it whatever you want we all knew nothing was coming to save us. We sharpened our swords and barricade our homes. The creatures would find us, just like they found all the other cities.
"Custom demanded that Prince Urban get a love mark tattooed to the side of his left eye as an infant, just like the rest of his people, but to him, the stupid things have only brought on the scorn of his father, the misery of his siblings, and caused his entire kingdom to go broke from fighting so many wars over the irritating ink stains.
When Urban’s sister must travel to Donnelly, the kingdom within the sand, for her arranged marriage to align two realms, he goes with her. But he no sooner steps foot inside their castle than his mark starts itching like a son of a bitch, telling him his one true love is near.
It just figures, though, that the woman meant for him is completely forbidden. Now he must decide if he should ignore the persistent mark, telling him she's the one, in order to avoid a possible war between kingdoms, or if he should discover whether she's worth risking everything for so they can be together. Either way, his life gets sucked into chaos with threats of beheadings, dark magic lurking, castle traitors scheming, and sword fights eminent.
Who knew one little tattoo could cause so much trouble?
(ONE TRUE LOVE is the author’s first attempt at a fantasy romance. Please forgive her; she might’ve read an overabundance of Cassandra Gannon, Sarah J. Maas, and Eve Langlais books, then gone off to watch too many episodes of Supernatural, Game of Thrones, and Outlander, because this was the outcome.)"
Alaric Thorn was just a blacksmith in the 12th century—a husband, a father, a simple man.
Until the day everything was taken from him.
His wife murdered.
His daughters stolen.
And he himself slaughtered, powerless to protect the people he loved.
But death did not end his story.
Dragged into a supernatural realm after dying, Alaric made a desperate bargain:
power in exchange for completing a mission in the future.
A mission he did not understand.
He returned to Earth centuries later—only to realize his revenge no longer existed.
Four hundred years had passed.
His family long gone.
Their killer long dead.
And Alaric… could no longer die.
Cursed with immortality, he wandered through ages and empires, trying every possible way to end his life—failing each time. All he wanted was to go back in time and fix what he had lost.
But when he finally stepped into a time machine, fate betrayed him again.
Instead of the past…
Alaric was thrown into another realm entirely—a brutal world crawling with monsters, ancient races, and system-like powers. Here, strength must be earned through blood, each battle pushing him closer to awakening his true potential.
In this realm, he is no longer just a wanderer.
He is a rising lord.
A conqueror.
A man destined to build an empire strong enough to challenge a king—
a king who bears the same name as the monster who destroyed his life on Earth.
As Alaric fights beasts, defeats tyrants, and gathers allies and armies, he discovers the truth behind the mission he accepted centuries ago:
To reclaim his fate…
To break his immortal curse…
To rewrite the destiny stolen from him…
He must rise as the Immortal King.
The true master of the Dark Realm he was fated to rule.
War is coming, and this time it is more than personal.
For generations, the Stormborn lineage has carried one story like a scar, the former Draconis destroyed their empire and left their bloodline in ruins. The Red Alpha grew up on that story.
He was raised on it.
Fed with it.
Every lesson, every battle, every scar carved one belief into him, when the Draconis rises again, it must be put to death.
But fate has a cruel sense of humor.
Because the new Draconis is Lyra.
She doesn’t fully understand what she is yet. She only knows she’s being hunted. Villages are being wiped out. Borders are closing. The wolf clan are preparing for open war. The vampire council is divided, each elder with their own hidden agenda. And somewhere deep within the forbidden forests lies a power that could either protect her or expose her.
The Red Alpha knows more than he admits. He knows what the last Draconis did. He knows secrets about Lyra’s blood that even she doesn’t know. And he is not just preparing for battle.
He is preparing revenge.
As the Blood Eclipse approaches, alliances will begin to crack, previous betrayals will surface again, and the truth about the former Draconis will threaten everything.
Because this isn’t just history repeating itself.
This is unfinished hatred.
And when Lyra finally steps into the fire, the world will learn whether she is their salvation...
Or the final mistake.
There's a recency bias, of course. A brilliant new release will dominate the 'must-read' conversation for months, sometimes eclipsing older classics. But the test is whether it's still recommended a year or two later, after the hype cycle ends. Books like 'Gideon the Ninth' or 'The Poppy War' passed that test, moving from 'hot new thing' to enduring staple. The Reddit definition has a temporal dimension—it's about sustained relevance, not just initial buzz.
Does anyone else get overwhelmed by choice? I'll read through one of these massive threads, add fifteen books to my cart, and then just freeze, unable to pick one. Analysis paralysis is real. Maybe the real 'best' book is the friends we made arguing about it online.
I treat those threads as a starting point for research, not a definitive guide. I'll scan the top twenty, note the ones that intrigue me, then go read professional reviews and samples. Reddit is great for gauging popular appeal and hearing reader experiences, but it lacks critical depth. It tells you what's loved, not always why it's significant from a craft perspective, which is crucial for a 'best of all time' designation.
Watching people try to quantify the unquantifiable is my guilty pleasure. 'On a scale of 1-10 for character development, prose, and thematic depth, my weighted algorithm gives 'Beloved' a 9.7, but 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' only a 9.4.' Please go outside and touch grass, my dude.