How Does Reddit Decide Which Fantasy Books Count As All Time Greats?

2026-07-14 17:36:07
39
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Start Test
Write Answer
Ask Question

6 Answers

WesSnow
WesSnow
Favorite read: The Dragons of Edon
Reviewer Mechanic
Hmm, never really thought about how it happens. I just absorb the recommendations by osmosis, I guess. My reading list is basically a reflection of whatever r/Fantasy has hyped this month.
2026-07-15 14:20:25
2
Book Clue Finder Editor
It’s a mix of genuine admiration and community in-jokes. 'Malazan' is a great example—part of its status comes from the endless 'just keep reading, it all comes together' comments, which have become a rite of passage. The book's reputation is intertwined with a specific Reddit culture around it, which amplifies its perceived importance beyond its actual readership numbers.
2026-07-16 06:27:54
3
JunoDunn
JunoDunn
Favorite read: ERAGON THE DRAGON PRINCE
Bookworm Assistant
Sometimes it's the memes. 'The bonehunters' , 'I am a stick', 'nice bird, asshole'—these inside jokes from various series serve as constant, low-level advertising. They keep a book present in the community's mind even when it's not the direct topic of discussion. This ambient presence contributes to a feeling of ubiquity, which translates to 'greatness'.
2026-07-17 08:09:05
1
SadieNeal
SadieNeal
Spoiler Watcher Photographer
The whole concept of 'all-time greats' on Reddit is heavily skewed toward modern, post-2000 epic fantasy. You’ll see Tolkien and maybe Le Guin as the obligatory old guard, but the list quickly fills with contemporary doorstoppers. This isn't necessarily wrong, but it reflects the demographic of Reddit's user base—readers who grew up with Jordan, Martin, and Sanderson. Classic sword-and-sorcery or older weird fiction often gets overlooked unless a dedicated niche subreddit pushes for it. So Reddit’s canon is really 'Reddit’s favorite fantasy from the last few decades,' which is a useful but incomplete snapshot.
2026-07-17 20:59:22
3
EdieGray
EdieGray
Library Roamer Editor
Through exhaustive list-making. Reddit loves lists. 'Top 25 Fantasy Series of All Time' posts generate thousands of comments comparing and arguing. The aggregate of all these lists, created by users with different tastes, creates a blurred-average picture of the greats. Books that appear consistently across many different users' personal lists are the ones that earn the title. It’s crowdsourced canon formation.
2026-07-18 09:42:18
2
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

How do Reddit fantasy readers define a must-read fantasy book?

4 Answers2026-07-14 11:26:33
There's a recency bias, of course. A brilliant new release will dominate the 'must-read' conversation for months, sometimes eclipsing older classics. But the test is whether it's still recommended a year or two later, after the hype cycle ends. Books like 'Gideon the Ninth' or 'The Poppy War' passed that test, moving from 'hot new thing' to enduring staple. The Reddit definition has a temporal dimension—it's about sustained relevance, not just initial buzz.

How does Reddit shape lists of the best fantasy books for adults?

5 Answers2026-07-14 20:06:24
Does anyone else get overwhelmed by choice? I'll read through one of these massive threads, add fifteen books to my cart, and then just freeze, unable to pick one. Analysis paralysis is real. Maybe the real 'best' book is the friends we made arguing about it online.

How does Reddit shape lists of the best fiction books of all time?

3 Answers2026-07-15 07:14:02
I treat those threads as a starting point for research, not a definitive guide. I'll scan the top twenty, note the ones that intrigue me, then go read professional reviews and samples. Reddit is great for gauging popular appeal and hearing reader experiences, but it lacks critical depth. It tells you what's loved, not always why it's significant from a craft perspective, which is crucial for a 'best of all time' designation.

How do Reddit reading communities debate all time best fiction books?

5 Answers2026-07-15 18:47:24
Watching people try to quantify the unquantifiable is my guilty pleasure. 'On a scale of 1-10 for character development, prose, and thematic depth, my weighted algorithm gives 'Beloved' a 9.7, but 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' only a 9.4.' Please go outside and touch grass, my dude.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status