What Role Did David Grohl Nirvana Play In MTV Unplugged?

That MTV-set still hits me in odd ways years later — the performance on 'MTV Unplugged in New York' felt like an intimate confession more than a concert. The complete sequence they recorded and released on the album goes like this: 'About a Girl', 'Come as You Are', 'Jesus Doesn't Want Me for a Sunbeam' (a tender take on The Vaselines), 'The Man Who Sold the World' (David Bowie cover), 'Pennyroyal Tea', 'Dumb', 'Polly', 'On a Plain', 'Something in the Way', then three Meat Puppets covers 'Plateau', 'Oh, Me', 'Lake of Fire' with the Kirkwood brothers joining onstage, followed by 'All Apologies', and ending on that raw, haunting 'Where Did You Sleep Last Night' (Lead Belly cover). What I treasure most are the little textures — the cello backing, the quiet backing vocals, and how Kurt's voice cracks in exactly the right places. The Bowie and Lead Belly covers stand out because they recontextualize the originals; the Meat Puppets songs add a weird country-folk flavor that plays well against Nirvana's more fragile numbers. It was recorded on November 18, 1993, and you can hear the mood of the room. Listening now, I still get chills.

That 'MTV Unplugged' session has a kind of quiet thunder to it, and I still get pulled into its world every few months. If you want a clean list of the songs Kurt Cobain performs (meaning the ones he wrote and sang) during that set, here’s how I break it down — the show mixes originals with covers, so I’ll separate the Cobain-written pieces from the rest and mention the context because the atmosphere matters as much as the songs. On the official 'MTV Unplugged in New York' release the Kurt Cobain-penned songs featured are: About a Girl; Come as You Are; Pennyroyal Tea; Dumb; Polly; On a Plain; Something in the Way; and All Apologies. Those are the core Nirvana originals he sings solo or with the band in that intimate acoustic arrangement. The set also includes a few covers and guest spots — for example, the Meat Puppets join for Plateau, Oh, Me and Lake of Fire, and Cobain covers David Bowie’s The Man Who Sold the World and The Vaselines’ Jesus Doesn’t Want Me for a Sunbeam. The haunting closer, Where Did You Sleep Last Night, is a traditional/Lead Belly arrangement rather than a Cobain original. Listening to those Cobain originals unplugged is such a different experience compared with the studio or electric live versions. About a Girl feels so vulnerable stripped down, Come as You Are turns almost conversational, and All Apologies lands with this devastating, tender resignation that still hits me in the chest. The set’s balance — originals that reveal Cobain’s songwriting, plus covers that showcase his taste and influences — is what makes the performance timeless to me. Every time I hear Polly or Dumb in that space, I notice new lines, little vocal inflections, and the way the silence between chords matters as much as the chords themselves. It’s one of those recordings where the songwriting stands naked and you can’t help but feel it, and I always come away a little changed.