How Do The Sun And The Star Reviews Compare To Previous Books?

2026-06-21 22:52:58
148
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Start Test
Write Answer
Ask Question

4 Answers

Kyle
Kyle
Favorite read: Kiss Of A Fallen Star
Longtime Reader Driver
Man, the reviews for 'The Sun and the Star' have been... all over the place, honestly. Compared to the hype around earlier books like 'The Son of Neptune' or even the original 'The Lightning Thief', the reception feels a lot more muted. A lot of fans I've talked to were excited for a Nico-centric story, and while they delivered that, the pacing felt off. It's slower, more introspective.

I loved the dive into Nico and Will's dynamic, don't get me wrong, but the plot's journey through Tartarus again kind of lacked the high-stakes urgency of Percy and Annabeth's trip. The reviews I've seen split pretty cleanly: people there for the character growth and queer romance adored it, while readers craving the classic, propulsive Riordan adventure felt it meandered. It's definitely a 'vibes' book more than a plot-heavy one, which sets it apart.

For me, the character moments shine, but it doesn't have the same widespread, breathless acclaim the earlier series entries got. The quieter, more emotional focus seems to have divided the fandom more than unified it.
2026-06-22 12:50:00
13
Zane
Zane
Favorite read: Blood and Moonlight
Frequent Answerer Mechanic
I actually disagree with a lot of the negative takes. Comparing it to previous books isn't entirely fair because it's a different kind of story. It's not a sprawling epic with a huge new cast; it's a deeply personal, claustrophobic road trip for two characters. Reviews that call it 'slow' or 'less exciting' are missing the point—it's supposed to be a character study. The earlier novels were about saving the world; this one is about saving each other from their own trauma. That shift in scale and tone was always going to resonate differently. So yeah, the reviews are more polarized, but I think that's because it dared to be a quieter, more niche entry in a universe known for its big, crowd-pleasing adventures. It's a compliment in a way.
2026-06-22 17:22:46
10
Eva
Eva
Frequent Answerer Teacher
Most reviews I've seen praise the representation and the heart of Nico and Will's relationship, which was overdue. But a lot of them also note the plot feels thin, like a novella stretched into a novel. Compared to the tight, puzzle-like plots of 'The Titan's Curse' or 'The Battle of the Labyrinth', it just doesn't have the same narrative momentum. It's a good book, but not a standout in the overall series.
2026-06-23 14:10:46
3
Orion
Orion
Ending Guesser Librarian
The difference in reviews is stark when you look at aggregate sites. Earlier Riordan books tend to sit in the high 4-star range on Goodreads with tens of thousands of ratings. 'The Sun and the Star' dipped lower pretty quickly, currently hovering around a 3.8. That tells a story right there. A common thread in the critical reviews is the feeling that it retreads ground—Tartarus again, but with less visceral peril. The humor's also different; less sarcastic kid-energy from Nico, more earnest teen emotional labor. Some readers found that maturity refreshing, others missed the sharper edges. It's clearly a book written for a specific segment of the fanbase that's grown up with the characters, rather than aiming for the universal appeal of the original quests.
2026-06-27 01:32:01
3
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

Is The Moon and the Sun worth reading?

3 Answers2026-03-24 04:38:00
I picked up 'The Moon and the Sun' on a whim after seeing its gorgeous cover, and wow, it totally swept me away! This isn’t your typical historical fantasy—it’s this lush, baroque adventure where Louis XIV’s court tries to capture a mermaid. The prose feels like biting into a rich dessert; Vonda McIntyre blends science, politics, and myth so elegantly. Marie-Josèphe, the protagonist, is such a refreshing voice—curious, rebellious, and stuck in this glittering cage of Versailles. The way McIntyre contrasts her scientific mind with the superstitions of the era? Chef’s kiss. What really hooked me, though, was how the book twists expectations. The mermaid isn’t just a prop—she’s a mirror to humanity’s cruelty and wonder. Some sections drag a tad with courtly detail, but honestly, that just made the world feel more real. If you love historical fiction with teeth (or scales), this one’s a hidden gem. I finished it with that bittersweet ache of wanting to stay in its world longer.

What are the reviews for the mornîng star novel on Goodreads?

5 Answers2025-04-29 05:10:19
I recently dove into 'Morning Star' and the Goodreads reviews are a mixed bag, but overwhelmingly positive. Many readers praised the intense character development, especially the protagonist’s journey from a broken rebel to a fierce leader. The pacing is relentless, with twists that leave you gasping. Some mentioned the emotional depth, particularly in the relationships, which felt raw and real. A few critics felt the ending was a bit rushed, but most agreed it was a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy. The world-building continues to shine, with vivid descriptions that make you feel like you’re right there in the chaos. Overall, it’s a must-read for fans of the series, and even newcomers who love epic sci-fi with heart. One thing that stood out in the reviews was the moral complexity of the story. It’s not just about good vs. evil; it’s about the gray areas in between. Readers appreciated how the author didn’t shy away from tough decisions and their consequences. The action sequences were another highlight, described as cinematic and adrenaline-pumping. A few people mentioned they had to take breaks because the tension was so high. If you’re into stories that challenge your perspective and keep you on the edge of your seat, 'Morning Star' delivers in spades.

Are there any reviews for The Morning Sun book?

2 Answers2025-12-03 18:44:29
I picked up 'The Morning Sun' a few months ago after hearing whispers about it in online book circles, and wow, it really stuck with me. The prose is so vivid—it feels like you're walking through the protagonist's world, tasting the salt in the air and feeling the weight of their choices. Reviews I’ve seen echo this; many readers praise its emotional depth and the way it tackles themes of redemption and quiet resilience. Some critics call it 'slow burn,' but that’s part of its charm—the way it simmers until everything boils over in the final act. One thing that divides opinion is the nonlinear structure. I personally loved how it mirrored the protagonist’s fragmented memories, but I’ve seen forum threads where folks found it disorienting. Also, the secondary characters—especially the protagonist’s estranged sister—are either hailed as brilliantly nuanced or criticized for being underdeveloped. Depends who you ask! For me, the book’s imperfections made it feel more human, like finding cracks in an old painting that tell their own story.

Is 'The Sun and Other Stars' worth reading?

3 Answers2026-03-08 20:10:43
The first thing that struck me about 'The Sun and Other Stars' was how effortlessly it blends humor and heartbreak. It’s one of those rare books that feels like a warm hug even when it’s exploring deeply emotional themes. The protagonist’s journey through grief and love is so raw and real that I found myself laughing one minute and tearing up the next. The way the author captures small-town life and the complexities of family dynamics is just perfection. It’s not a flashy, high-stakes story, but that’s what makes it shine—it’s quietly brilliant. If you enjoy character-driven narratives with soul, this is absolutely worth your time. What really stayed with me, though, was the book’s treatment of soccer (or football, depending where you’re from!). It’s woven into the story in such a unique way, almost like a secondary character. I’m not even a sports fan, but the way the game ties into the protagonist’s healing process was incredibly moving. The relationships feel authentic, from the messy friendships to the strained family bonds. It’s a book that lingers—I still catch myself thinking about certain scenes months later.

Is Sun and Shadow worth reading?

4 Answers2026-03-25 15:20:53
I stumbled upon 'Sun and Shadow' while browsing for something fresh, and wow, it hooked me from the first chapter. The way it blends gritty realism with poetic descriptions of its coastal setting feels like a love letter to both place and people. The protagonist’s struggle between duty and desire isn’t groundbreaking, but the author’s knack for making every internal conflict viscerally relatable kept me turning pages. What really shines is the supporting cast—each character feels like they’ve lived a full life off-page, especially the protagonist’s estranged sister, whose sharp dialogue steals every scene. It’s not perfect (the middle drags a bit), but the payoff in the final act? Pure catharsis. I finished it in two sittings and immediately loaned my copy to a friend.

What do readers say in the sun and the star reviews?

4 Answers2026-06-21 17:38:50
I've read dozens of user reviews for 'The Sun and the Star' across Goodreads and fan forums, and the general sentiment feels deeply split, almost like two different books are being discussed. On one side, you have readers who adored the central journey between Nico di Angelo and Will Solace. Many reviews highlight how seeing their relationship explored in such a dedicated, intimate narrative was a long-awaited payoff. They praise the quieter, more introspective moments and the way it deals with Nico's trauma from past series in a more direct way than before. The emotional core really resonated with this group. On the flip side, a significant portion of reviews criticize the pacing, calling it meandering or slow, especially in the middle sections of the Underworld trek. Some felt the plot was thin, more a vehicle for character moments than a compelling adventure in its own right, which didn't work for everyone. There's also chatter about the writing style feeling different from Riordan's main entries, which some found jarring. A recurring note in the critical reviews is a wish for more balance—they wanted the great character work but within a tighter, more eventful story. Personally, I fall somewhere in the middle; I loved the characters but found myself skimming a few chapters.

Are the sun and the star reviews positive or negative overall?

4 Answers2026-06-21 13:13:44
it feels like the reviews are all over the place. My main takeaway is that people who adore Nico and Will as a couple seem to overwhelmingly love it. The book delivers on the relationship front in a way fans have wanted for years, giving them a proper, high-stakes adventure together. The emotional core is really strong if you're invested in these characters. But then there's a significant chunk of readers, including some longtime Riordan fans, who found the pacing off. The journey through Tartarus felt less terrifying the second time around, and some plot elements seemed recycled. It's not a unanimous love-fest like some of the earlier books. Overall, I'd call the reception warmly positive with notable, specific criticisms, not a negative wave. The goodreads score hovering around 4 stars tells that story—solid, but not his peak.

What themes do the sun and the star reviews highlight most?

4 Answers2026-06-21 12:25:23
I finally got around to 'The Sun and the Star' after loving the earlier 'Solstice' books, and the reviews I read beforehand seemed laser-focused on one thing: the central friendship between Nico and Will. It wasn't just about them getting together; it was about the quiet, steady way they support each other through literal and emotional darkness. A lot of folks online pointed out how the book handles themes of recovery and carrying trauma, but without the story becoming overwhelmingly grim. Nico's past isn't brushed aside, but the narrative lets him breathe and find a bit of light, which many reviewers found genuinely moving. The underworld journey served more as a backdrop for their conversations than just an action sequence. What surprised me was how many comments mentioned the writing itself, calling out specific lines that balanced melancholy with warmth. That careful tone seems to be what stuck with people most.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status