Why Is 'The Better Angels Of Our Nature' Controversial?

2025-06-30 08:25:04 330
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test

3 Answers

Rachel
Rachel
2025-07-01 05:41:31
The firestorm around 'The Better Angels of Our Nature' fascinates me because it reveals how differently people interpret historical patterns. Pinker's decision to measure violence primarily through death rates creates immediate tension - activists argue this ignores psychological trauma, cultural destruction, and slow violence like environmental damage.

His treatment of indigenous peoples causes particular outrage. By focusing on intertribal warfare rates, Pinker implies European colonization reduced violence, which indigenous scholars reject as justifying their subjugation. The book's emphasis on state formation as a violence reducer also draws criticism for overlooking how states themselves became instruments of mass violence.

What's compelling is how the controversy mirrors larger debates about Enlightenment values. Pinker positions science and humanism as drivers of peace, but post-colonial thinkers note these same ideologies enabled imperialism. The book's optimistic determinism - the idea we're inevitably becoming less violent - feels naive to those studying rising authoritarianism today. Yet even critics admit Pinker started crucial conversations about how we measure and conceptualize violence across eras.
Xavier
Xavier
2025-07-03 17:50:09
I've read 'The Better Angels of Our Nature' multiple times, and the controversy largely stems from its bold claim that violence has declined over human history. Many critics argue Pinker cherry-picks data to support his thesis, ignoring periods of extreme violence like colonial atrocities or modern conflicts. The book's heavy reliance on statistical analysis rubs some historians the wrong way, as they believe numbers can't capture the full complexity of human suffering. Some readers take issue with the optimistic tone, feeling it minimizes current problems by comparing them to worse historical periods. The section on modern warfare particularly divides opinion, as Pinker suggests nuclear weapons paradoxically prevented large-scale wars, which many find morally questionable. His treatment of non-Western societies also draws criticism for allegedly downplaying their historical experiences of violence.
Emma
Emma
2025-07-04 10:50:45
the controversy operates on multiple levels. The central argument about declining violence challenges deeply held beliefs about human nature and progress, making scholars from various disciplines push back hard.

One major critique comes from anthropologists who dispute Pinker's characterization of prehistoric societies as exceptionally violent. They point to newer archaeological evidence suggesting early humans weren't constantly at war. Political scientists question his interpretation of modern conflicts, arguing that while battlefield deaths may have decreased, other forms of structural violence like economic oppression have increased.

The psychological aspects spark debate too. Pinker's thesis leans heavily on the idea that reason and enlightenment values reduce violence, but critics counter that these same values justified colonialism and slavery. The book's treatment of the 20th century is especially contentious - while acknowledging world wars and genocides, Pinker frames them as exceptions in a broader trend toward peace, which some Holocaust scholars find offensive.

What makes the controversy persist is how the book intersects with contemporary politics. Some see it as providing intellectual cover for complacency about current injustices, while others praise it for challenging pervasive doom-and-gloom narratives. The data visualization techniques Pinker employs also draw fire, with statisticians noting how different graphical representations could tell opposite stories from the same numbers.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Someone Better
Someone Better
Kendra found out her boyfriend cheated on her while in a long distance relationship after visiting him. Kendra just loses her grandmother who raised her and needed someone to cheer her up that's why she decided to visit her boyfriend. But she did not expect to hear this: "Harder James! Harder!" A soft growl came from inside his apartment. "Oh yeah baby!" James replied. Kendra was stunned as she knelt outside the door of James' apartment..
8
|
108 Chapters
The Scarlet Angels
The Scarlet Angels
While solving one of the cases, detective Esther Moore comes across a legend that grandmother told her long ago. Soon the line between what is real and what is not gradually blurs. Are the legendary 'Scarlet Angels' real or is Esther losing her mind?
Not enough ratings
|
50 Chapters
DIRTY ANGELS
DIRTY ANGELS
If you’re filthy minded, step inside the doors of Dirty Angels and order a drink. Dirty Angels is a cocktail bar where desire, power, and bad decisions collide. Everyone who walks through its doors is hiding something, and everyone wants something they shouldn’t. The story unfolds through rotating points of view, each character given five chapters at a time to reveal the dirty business they’re involved in. Mafia deals. Billionaire secrets. Bad boys with dangerous appetites. Obsessions that refuse to stay buried. Each arc can be read on its own, but together they weave into a larger, darker story as the full truth behind Dirty Angels slowly comes into focus. At the centre are Marisol and Ethan, locked in a volatile enemies-to-lovers dynamic neither of them is willing to name. Around them orbit lovers, rivals, and predators: a mafia ex who won’t let go, a billionaire with too much power, a shark lawyer who knows exactly where the bodies are buried, and a found family bound together by loyalty, desire, and shared secrets. Dirty Angels attracts those who crave the forbidden. Boundaries blur. Power shifts hands. Desire takes many forms, and not everyone is looking for love. Some will find it anyway. Others will burn everything down on the way. Tropes & Themes: Enemies to lovers • MM • MMF • FF • Power dynamics • Daddy energy • Age gap (all adults) • Step-relations (adults) • BDSM themes • Obsession • Found family • Dark desire
10
|
85 Chapters
Better Brother, Better Life
Better Brother, Better Life
At the very moment Phoebe Stanton miscarries, her husband, Connor Russell, is celebrating the return of his first love. To him, her three years of devotion and companionship mean nothing more than being a live-in maid and cook. Phoebe gives up on him and decides to divorce. Everyone in their circle knows that Phoebe is clingy and impossible to shake off. "I bet she'll come crawling in a day." Connor sneers. "A day? That's too long—half a day at most." But the moment Phoebe signs the divorce papers, she decides never to look back. She throws herself into a new life. She revives her career, which she once abandoned, builds new connections, and meets new people. As time goes on, Connor no longer sees even a trace of Phoebe at home. He begins to panic. At an industry summit, he finally spots her, surrounded by admirers. Desperate, he pushes forward. "Phoebe, haven't you had enough of this tantrum?" But Gideon Blackwood suddenly steps in front of her, shoving Connor aside, his very demeanor chilling the air. "Don't touch my woman." Connor has never loved Phoebe. But now that he does, it's already too late. There's no longer a place for him in her world.
10
|
610 Chapters
Nadia By Nature
Nadia By Nature
Tired of being a Sub, Nadia takes on a role of a Dom, but all that changes in a blink of an eye. A series of events leave her at the mercy of a man she never thought she'd see again. Will she be able to escape her past? Or is her past back to punish her? "Remember the safe word Nadia." "Red" She breathlessly answered.
10
|
28 Chapters
For Better, Not Yours
For Better, Not Yours
On the eve of my engagement banquet, news broke that my fiancé had fathered a child with his mistress, and it spread like wildfire. Before I could confront him, Jayden Ford brushed it off casually. "It was just an accident. Focus on organizing the engagement banquet first. Besides, your dad’s in the late stages of stomach cancer. Calling off the engagement now won’t do either family any good." That night, he skipped the banquet but posted a photo of a swaddled newborn on social media. When I video-called him, he was bottle-feeding the baby. "I’ve been busy taking care of the kid. You know how it is. Our family lineage has always been sparse and dwindling, and the child takes priority." He wiped milk from the baby’s mouth. "But don’t worry. Once he’s a month old, I’ll send him to the overseas. Just show up on holidays and pretend to be his mom. The title of Mrs. Ford will always be yours." I stared at the matching diamond ring on his finger and couldn’t help but laugh. "Jayden, this engagement is off." He scoffed, "You're really throwing a tantrum over something like this? Don’t be so childish." I hung up on him and called his father—Charles Ford—directly. "I heard you’re looking for a new wife? Why not consider me?" I ran a hand over my belly and smiled. "After all, I’ve got a naturally fertile body. I can give you as many sons as you want." So much for being the sole heir. I’ll make sure he has plenty of brothers to keep him company.
|
10 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Is The Author Of 'Angels In My Closet'?

5 Answers2025-06-16 15:49:06
The author of 'Angels in My Closet' is M. Tamara, a relatively new but deeply insightful writer who specializes in blending supernatural elements with heartfelt human stories. Her background in psychology gives her characters a rich emotional depth that resonates with readers. The novel itself explores themes of loss, redemption, and unseen forces guiding our lives, all wrapped in a gripping narrative. M. Tamara's writing style is lyrical yet accessible, making her work appealing to both casual readers and literary enthusiasts. What sets her apart is how she weaves everyday struggles with the extraordinary—angels aren't just ethereal beings but mirrors reflecting the protagonist's inner battles. Her attention to detail in crafting spiritual lore feels fresh, avoiding clichés while staying rooted in universal emotions. Fans of 'Angels in My Closet' often praise how she balances suspense with tenderness, a hallmark of her storytelling.

How Is Nature Depicted In The Interlopers Book?

3 Answers2025-12-21 15:14:20
Nature in 'The Interlopers' is portrayed with this beautiful yet ominous touch, which really adds depth to the unfolding climax. The setting takes place in the Carpathian Mountains, and the descriptions paint a vivid picture of towering trees and a wintry wilderness that seems almost alive. I couldn't help but feel this sense of foreboding as the two men, Ulrich and Georg, trap themselves under falling branches during a fierce storm. It’s like the forest itself is meditating on their conflict, watching them as rivals in a long-standing feud. Their struggle against nature becomes a physical representation of their inner fights, and the way the elements are personified adds an emotional weight to the story. Nature isn't just a backdrop here; it's a central character in its own right. As the reader, I felt a sense of isolation as the trees closed in on them. The biting cold and swirling snow didn't merely serve to disorient the characters; they mirrored the hostility between the two men. Moreover, the dramatic, merciless environment highlights how small human squabbles are in the grand scheme of things. When they finally set their differences aside, you can’t help but find it poignant that something as eternal and indifferent as nature has made them realize the futility of their feud. The storyline wraps you in layers of hope, despair, and a bittersweet sense of regret, which makes you reflect on your own conflicts in life. Lastly, the ending punch—nature delivering a brutal twist when the wolves come to claim their dues—drove home the message: nature is relentless and unyielding. It serves as a stark reminder of our vulnerability, reminding me of nature's raw power over human endeavors. This interplay between the characters and their landscape really kept me thinking long after turning the last page.

How Can Authors Better Include Aroace Characters In Their Works?

5 Answers2025-10-08 10:04:00
It's fascinating to dive into how authors can effectively include aroace characters in their narratives. From my perspective as a long-time reader of both books and manga, one of the most empowering ways to approach this is through authentic representation. Rather than making aroace characters feel like plot devices or mere tokens, it's crucial for their experiences and identities to be woven seamlessly into the fabric of the story. Authors could also benefit from researching and understanding the nuances of asexuality and aromanticism. This could be achieved through engaging with aroace communities, reading first-hand accounts, and maybe even interviewing individuals within these identities to capture their realities authentically. Incorporating moments that highlight the unique perspectives of aroace characters can deepen the richness of a narrative. For instance, showing them forming close relationships — whether they’re platonic or familial — can help emphasize their identities without solely focusing on romantic or sexual dynamics. Thinking outside the box while developing their character arcs can also lead to unexpected and delightful interactions that resonate with readers. Lastly, providing aroace characters access to well-rounded narratives with their own personal conflicts and journeys is essential. For instance, some aroace people might face societal pressures about relationships in ways that others do not, and exploring these themes can add emotional depth and relatability. When each character is treated with the respect and attention they deserve, stories blossom, inviting all readers into worlds that feel real and inclusive.

Which Kuroo X Kenma Fanfics Focus On Kenma'S Introversion And Kuroo'S Protective Nature?

3 Answers2025-05-12 13:52:06
I’ve come across some remarkable 'Kuroo x Kenma' fanfics that emphasize Kenma’s introverted side, highlighting his struggle to navigate social interactions. One favorite features Kuroo taking on a protective role during a school event, ensuring Kenma feels comfortable while also pushing him gently out of his comfort zone. The way Kuroo recognizes subtle cues from Kenma is beautifully done, showcasing their dynamic. Another story dives into Kenma’s gaming world, with Kuroo teaming up with him in a virtual realm, creating a safe space for Kenma to shine without overwhelming real-life pressures. It’s heartwarming to see their relationship blossom in environments where Kenma feels at home, amplifying both their personalities perfectly. This portrayal really illustrates how Kuroo helps Kenma emerge from his shell while respecting his boundaries. The balance of their strengths is just delightful to read.

How Does Danmachi Fanfic Reinterpret Hestia'S Protective Nature Towards Bell In A Romantic Light?

4 Answers2025-05-07 05:21:45
Hestia’s protective nature in 'DanMachi' fanfics often gets reimagined with a romantic twist, and I’ve seen some fascinating takes. Writers love to explore her feelings evolving from maternal care to something deeper, blending her goddess-like devotion with human vulnerability. One recurring theme is Hestia struggling with her emotions, torn between her duty as a goddess and her growing affection for Bell. These stories often highlight her jealousy in subtle ways—like her reactions to Bell’s interactions with Ais or other female adventurers. I’ve read fics where Hestia’s protective instincts lead her to make bold decisions, like stepping into battles to shield Bell or using her divine powers in ways that risk her own safety. The best ones delve into her internal conflict, showing her grappling with the idea of loving a mortal and the potential heartbreak that comes with it. Some even explore alternate universes where Hestia and Bell are equals, stripping away the divine-mortal dynamic to focus on their emotional connection. It’s a delicate balance, but when done right, it adds layers to Hestia’s character that the original series only hints at. Another angle I’ve noticed is how fanfics reimagine Hestia’s protective nature as a catalyst for Bell’s growth. Instead of just shielding him, she becomes his emotional anchor, helping him navigate the challenges of being an adventurer. These stories often show Hestia teaching Bell about trust and vulnerability, creating a bond that feels both tender and profound. I’ve come across fics where Hestia’s love for Bell inspires her to confront her own insecurities, like her fear of being forgotten or replaced. It’s a beautiful exploration of how love can transform even a goddess, making her more relatable and human. The romantic reinterpretation of Hestia’s protective nature adds depth to her character, turning her into more than just a doting guardian. It’s a testament to how fanfiction can breathe new life into familiar dynamics, offering fresh perspectives on beloved characters.

Are Complex Storylines Better For Mystery Books?

2 Answers2026-04-15 08:09:43
Complex storylines in mystery books can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, they offer readers a labyrinth of clues, red herrings, and layered character motivations that make the payoff incredibly satisfying when everything clicks. Take 'The Name of the Rose' by Umberto Eco—every page feels like peeling back another layer of an onion, with historical context, theological debates, and a murder mystery all intertwined. But that complexity demands patience. Not everyone wants to juggle a dozen suspects, cryptic symbols, and shifting timelines just to get to the 'aha' moment. Some readers prefer the streamlined tension of Agatha Christie's 'And Then There Were None,' where the focus is tight, the cast is contained, and the puzzle is elegant without being overwhelming. Personally, I adore a mystery that makes me work for it, but only if the complexity serves the story. When it feels like the author is just showing off or burying weak character development under convoluted plots, it backfires. A great complex mystery, like 'Gone Girl,' balances twists with emotional stakes—you’re not just solving a crime, you’re unraveling human nature. But if I’m in the mood for something quick and atmospheric, I’ll reach for Raymond Chandler instead, where the pleasure is in the smoky dialogue and hard-boiled simplicity. It really depends on what kind of mental workout I’m craving.

Is Learn English With Book Better Than Apps?

4 Answers2025-07-26 19:30:28
I firmly believe learning English with books offers a depth and richness that apps can't match. Books immerse you in natural language, exposing you to complex sentence structures, nuanced vocabulary, and cultural contexts that are often simplified in apps. Reading 'Harry Potter' or 'To Kill a Mockingbird' doesn't just teach grammar—it shows how language flows in real narratives. Apps are great for drills, but books provide the emotional connection to language that makes learning stick. Moreover, books allow you to explore topics you're genuinely passionate about, whether it's sci-fi, romance, or history. This intrinsic motivation is crucial for long-term learning. While apps like Duolingo gamify the process, they often lack the sustained engagement of a good novel. I've found that my vocabulary expanded dramatically when I switched from app-based learning to reading 'The Hunger Games' series in English. The context clues in stories help you infer meanings naturally, just like how we learned our first language.

Where Can I Find Fanfiction Set In A Better World?

9 Answers2025-10-28 06:11:30
If you're hunting for fanfiction that rewrites the world into something kinder and calmer, start at Archive of Our Own (AO3) and treat the tag system like treasure maps. Search for tags like 'Fix-It', 'Uplifting', 'Healing', 'Canon Divergence', 'Domestic', 'Future Fic', or simply 'Hurt/Comfort'; combining them with your fandom of choice usually surfaces gems. I lean toward fandoms that naturally invite warm re-writes — 'Harry Potter' fix-its where a different choice prevents tragedy, 'Avatar: The Last Airbender' slice-of-life AUs, or 'Star Trek' stories that emphasize diplomacy and rebuilding. Beyond AO3, Wattpad and FanFiction.net have massive back catalogs (some real cult classics hide there), and Tumblr/Discord communities often curate recommendation lists for the gentler reads. I also use Google tricks like site:archiveofourown.org "happy ending" plus the fandom name. Don’t skip reading tags and authors’ notes — they’ll tell you whether it’s a cozy tea-and-blankets arc or a full world-rewrite utopia. Personally, curling up with a gentle 'fix-it' fic after a rough day feels like a warm blanket for the brain, and I come away oddly hopeful.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status