Who Wins The Trojan War In Homer'S Iliad?

2026-04-16 20:06:34
196
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Start Test
Write Answer
Ask Question

3 Answers

Quincy
Quincy
Favorite read: The Return of Medusa
Reply Helper Nurse
Technically, the Greeks win the Trojan War, but Homer's 'Iliad' stops short of showing it. The poem zeroes in on Achilles' sulk-turned-rampage and the clashes between warriors, leaving the big finale to other tales. What’s wild is how much the gods meddle—Apollo backs Troy, Athena cheers for Greece, and Zeus plays both sides. It’s less about strategy and more about divine egos. Even the wooden horse, the Greeks’ winning move, isn’t in the 'Iliad' at all! That’s like writing a heist story but skipping the actual robbery.

I love how later adaptations fill in the gaps, though. Euripides’ plays make the aftermath brutal—innocents slaughtered, queens enslaved—so the ‘victory’ feels hollow. The 'Iliad' itself is smarter, ending with Hector’s funeral, a quiet moment that undercuts the whole war’s point. The Greeks get their W, but Homer’s more interested in asking: ‘Was it worth it?’ Spoiler: Probably not.
2026-04-17 00:01:01
10
Story Interpreter Accountant
The Trojan War, as depicted in Homer's 'Iliad,' doesn't actually show the full resolution—it ends before the fall of Troy. But if we're talking about the broader mythos, the Greeks eventually win thanks to that infamous wooden horse trick. What fascinates me, though, is how the 'Iliad' focuses less on who wins and more on the human cost. Achilles' rage, Hector's doomed heroism, and the sheer pettiness of the gods make the war feel like a tragic spiral rather than a clear victory. The Greeks might take Troy, but Homer leaves you wondering if anyone really 'wins' in the end—especially with all the suffering piled up.

And let's not forget how later stories, like Virgil's 'Aeneid,' flip the script. The Trojans lose the war but go on to found Rome, which kinda feels like a cosmic do-over. The 'Iliad' is this raw, unfinished masterpiece where the ending isn't neat, and that's why it sticks with you. The Greeks 'win,' but the poem’s heart is in the messy middle, where glory and grief are tangled up forever.
2026-04-19 01:19:03
2
Rebecca
Rebecca
Story Interpreter Assistant
Greek forces take Troy, but the 'Iliad' doesn’t cover that part—it ends with Hector’s death and a temporary truce. The real climax comes from later legends: Odysseus’s wooden horse scheme, the city’s sack, and all that chaos. What gets me is how Homer frames the war as this grinding, god-driven mess where even ‘victors’ like Achilles don’t get happy endings. The poem’s more about the cost of pride and the futility of war than who wins. By the time the Greeks breach Troy’s walls, you’ve seen so much loss that the victory feels almost beside the point. Funny how the most famous war story avoids the actual battle finale.
2026-04-21 22:16:37
16
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

Which Iliad gods are involved in the Trojan War?

3 Answers2025-12-26 13:42:48
The 'Iliad' features a lively cast of deities who are deeply entrenched in the Trojan War, each bringing their unique personalities and agendas to the epic conflict. First up is Zeus, the king of the gods, who plays a crucial role in maintaining the balance of power. You’ll often find him in a precarious position, trying to stay neutral while overseeing the war's progress. It's fascinating how Zeus' decisions often reflect the tensions between fate and free will, as he wrestles with his desire to intervene and the inevitability of the war’s outcome. Then there’s Hera and Athena, who are both staunch supporters of the Greeks. Their animosity towards the Trojans is rooted in the infamous judgment of Paris, where Paris chose Aphrodite as the fairest over them. Hera, in particular, is relentless in her support, often scheming to tip the scales in favor of the Achaeans. Athena embodies strategic warfare and wisdom, which is why she takes an active interest in heroes like Odysseus and Achilles, constantly guiding them on the battlefield. Conversely, we have the goddesses supporting Troy: Aphrodite, who becomes an emblem of desire and defends Paris after he chose her as the winner of the golden apple. She ensures that Helen remains with him, which really ignites the whole conflict. There's also Apollo, the god of archery and prophecy, who stands firmly with the Trojans and sends plagues upon the Greeks to aid his side. In this cosmic chess game, these gods often showcase their complexities, embodying human emotions like jealousy, love, and revenge, which makes the epic deeply relatable even today. It's not just a war between men but a divine spectacle, full of drama and intrigue, that has captivated audiences for centuries.

Who won the Iliad war in the original epic poem?

4 Answers2025-08-01 00:52:21
'The Iliad' is a masterpiece that never fails to captivate me. The war itself doesn’t have a clear-cut winner in the traditional sense, but the Greeks ultimately achieve their goal. The poem ends with Hector’s funeral, but we know from other sources like 'The Odyssey' that Troy falls thanks to the infamous Trojan Horse. The Greeks, led by cunning Odysseus and mighty Achilles (before his demise), outsmart the Trojans after a grueling decade of battle. The real victory isn’t just about who won the war but the legacy of the characters. Achilles’ rage, Hector’s honor, and the gods’ meddling make the conflict unforgettable. The Greeks’ triumph is bittersweet—many heroes perish, and their return journeys (like in 'The Odyssey') are fraught with peril. The Iliad’s brilliance lies in its exploration of glory, fate, and the human cost of war, not just the outcome.

How does the story of the Iliad explain the Trojan War?

3 Answers2025-10-04 02:27:01
The tales woven into 'The Iliad' bring the Trojan War to life in such vivid detail, showing us just how complex and multifaceted it was. Now, think about it: the whole saga kicks off not just from a single spark of betrayal but from the nuances of human pride, divine intervention, and passion. It all begins with the beautiful Helen, who, arguably, becomes the catalyst for the war. When Paris, a Trojan prince, gives in to temptation and takes her away from Menelaus, it's like tossing a stone into a pond—the ripples create chaos across Greek and Trojan realms. But here’s the kicker: while 'The Iliad' focuses mainly on the latter stages of the war, the backstories of the key players are just as compelling. Achilles, the legendary Greek warrior, grapples not just with physical battles but with his own internal conflicts, particularly around honor and rage. His fury towards Agamemnon sets the stage for much of the drama and tragedy, leading to loss and a reflection of the human condition. The gods are also major players, meddling in mortal affairs, further complicating the narrative. What I find fascinating is how the story isn't just about war; it's poetry about loss, love, and the ephemeral nature of glory. The personal vendettas, friendships, and moral dilemmas create a rich tapestry that goes beyond just a historical event. In the end, it shapes our understanding not just of the war itself, but of what drives people to conflict in the first place.

How does the story of Iliad depict the Trojan War?

3 Answers2025-10-05 00:12:18
The story of the 'Iliad' presents the Trojan War through a multifaceted lens, creating a rich tapestry of heroism, conflict, and divine intervention. This epic, attributed to Homer, isn’t just a straightforward account of battles; it’s deeply embedded with emotional and psychological complexities. The war itself is depicted as a prolonged siege, where both sides are driven by honor, love, and vengeance. Achilles, for instance, represents the clash between personal honor and communal duty. His rage against Agamemnon for seizing Briseis doesn’t just lead to his withdrawal from battle; it showcases the themes of pride and the consequences of resentment. Throughout the narrative, the gods play a crucial role, often shifting the tide of battle based on petty disputes among themselves. This divine meddling poses an intriguing question about fate versus free will. Are the warriors mere pawns in a divine chess game, or do they have any agency in their destinies? The prophetic dreams and ominous portents serve as reminders of an inevitable fate, highlighting the futility of human efforts against the backdrop of cosmic indifference. The 'Iliad' also delves into the horrors of war and its toll on humanity. While it glorifies heroism through figures like Hector and Achilles, it doesn’t shy away from showing the brutal realities of warfare—the bloodshed, the loss of life, and the destruction of families. It’s this complexity that makes the 'Iliad' not just an ancient epic but a timeless meditation on the nature of conflict and heroism. It resonates with anyone who’s ever felt the pangs of betrayal or the burdens of duty, creating a sense of connection across centuries. As I reflect on these themes, it’s fascinating how contemporary stories often echo similar sentiments. Many modern narratives continue to grapple with the complexities of loyalty, love, and the consequences of our choices, much like the characters in the 'Iliad'. These timeless themes never seem to fade, making the ancient work feel fresh and relevant even today.

How does the iliad plot depict the Trojan War?

4 Answers2025-10-05 19:39:31
The plot of 'The Iliad' intricately weaves together the events of the Trojan War, primarily focusing on the fierce conflict between the Greeks and Trojans. This epic poem, attributed to Homer, casts a vivid light on the heroics, tragedies, and the complex interplay of divine influence over humanity. Centered around Achilles, a Greek warrior whose rage and pride ignite the tale, we see how personal grievances can overshadow the greater good of an entire campaign. Unfolding over just a few weeks during the tenth year of the war, it delves deeply into themes of honor, glory, and the fleeting nature of life. The war itself is depicted not just as a backdrop but a stage where the fate of entire civilizations hangs in the balance. Characters like Hector, the Trojan prince, embody valor and responsibility, contrasting with Achilles’ more individualistic approach. Through these characters, the poem reflects on human emotions and motivations, illustrating how pride, love, revenge, and fate intertwine. The gods are present, often intervening in humorous or tragic ways, which emphasizes the belief that human beings are at the mercy of greater forces. What’s truly compelling about this epic is its emphasis on personal narratives within the grand scheme of war. For instance, the scenes detailing the tragic fates of fallen heroes resonate deeply, giving readers a chance to reflect on the costs of conflict. It’s not merely a retelling of battles but a profound exploration of the hero’s journey, morality, and the quest for meaning amidst chaos, making it timeless and ageless.

How does the plot of Iliad unfold during the Trojan War?

5 Answers2025-10-11 21:25:33
In the grand tapestry of 'The Iliad,' the plot weaves together the intense drama of the Trojan War, focusing largely on the wrath of Achilles. The story kicks off with a quarrel between him and King Agamemnon, who has taken Achilles' war prize, Briseis. This personal conflict sets off a chain of events that spirals into the larger battle against the Trojans. What’s captivating is how Homer provides vivid descriptions of the battlefield, interspersing moments of valor with the deep emotional struggles of the characters involved. Throughout the narrative, we see gods and goddesses intervening, each backing their favored heroes, which adds layers of complexity to the already fierce competition. For instance, Athena supports the Greeks while Apollo champions the Trojans. The epic is rich with themes of honor, pride, and the human condition, making it resonate even today. Achilles’ journey—his wrath, his mourning for Patroclus, and eventual return to battle—is both personal and universal, encapsulating the tragic aspects of war. The plot doesn’t just dwell on battles; it digs deep into the psyche of its characters, allowing us to understand their motivations, fears, and the high cost of glory. It's fascinating how these ancient themes of love, loss, and honor echo in contemporary storytelling. It’s not just about heroes; it's about the costs they bear from their choices. The 'Iliad' serves as a reminder of the complexities that lie behind war, which is something we still grapple with in modern narratives.

Who won the Siege of Troy in Greek mythology?

4 Answers2026-04-21 18:35:43
Man, the Siege of Troy is one of those legendary tales that never gets old! After years of bloody battles and clever tricks, the Greeks finally pulled off that infamous Trojan Horse scheme. Imagine the Trojans waking up to find their city overrun—total chaos! Honestly, it’s wild how a giant wooden horse sealed their fate. The Greeks slaughtered most of the Trojans, burned Troy to the ground, and Helen went back to Menelaus. Talk about a dramatic ending! What fascinates me most is how this story keeps popping up in modern retellings, like 'Troy' (2004) or 'The Song of Achilles.' It’s proof that even ancient myths can feel fresh when told right. The blend of strategy, betrayal, and raw emotion makes it timeless. I still get chills thinking about Hector’s last stand or Odysseus’s cunning—those Greeks played the long game and won, but at what cost?
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status