Who Are The Main Characters In 'What If It’S Us'?

I recently finished 'What If It’s Us' and absolutely fell in love with the main characters. Arthur is this adorable, optimistic Broadway nerd from Georgia who’s interning in New York for the summer. He’s all about grand romantic gestures and believes in fate, which makes his perspective so refreshing. Then there’s Ben, a more reserved, introspective guy who’s just broken up with his boyfriend and is trying to figure out his next steps. Their dynamic is electric—Arthur’s spontaneity clashes and meshes perfectly with Ben’s cautious realism. What really stands out is how their personalities shape the story. Arthur’s theatrical flair brings this whimsical energy, while Ben’s grounded nature keeps things relatable. The side characters add depth too, like Dylan, Ben’s hilarious best friend who’s always cracking jokes, and Ethan, Arthur’s coworker who’s got this dry wit. The parents are also fleshed out—Arthur’s moms are supportive but overbearing, while Ben’s dad is struggling to connect with him post-divorce. It’s a story about two boys who meet by chance at a post office, and their journey feels so authentic because of how distinct their voices are.

The novel does a brilliant job of balancing humor and heart. Arthur’s over-the-top romanticism leads to some cringe-worthy but endearing moments, while Ben’s internal struggles make him incredibly sympathetic. Their differences create tension, but it’s the kind that makes you root for them even harder. The way they navigate misunderstandings and miscommunications feels painfully real, like when Arthur plans this elaborate date and Ben just isn’t on the same page. It’s a story about first love, but it’s also about growing up and realizing that relationships take work. The side characters aren’t just props—they have their own arcs, like Dylan’s loyalty or how Jessie, Ben’s ex, complicates things without being vilified. It’s a messy, beautiful portrayal of teenage love that sticks with you.