Is Simon The Villain In One Of Us Is Lying?

2026-04-28 12:04:14
184
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Start Test
Write Answer
Ask Question

4 Answers

Yara
Yara
Favorite read: Her Mate Is The Villain
Contributor Translator
I binged 'One of Us Is Lying' in a weekend, and Simon’s character stuck with me long after. Calling him a straight-up villain feels too simple. Sure, he’s the catalyst for all the chaos—his death kicks off the plot, and his app ruins lives. But the book peels back layers showing his loneliness and desperation for control. It’s hard not to see him as a product of Bayview High’s toxic environment. The way his backstory unfolds makes you question whether he’s truly evil or just a kid who cracked under pressure. That ambiguity is what makes the story so compelling—it refuses to paint anyone as purely good or bad.
2026-05-01 19:39:17
13
Addison
Addison
Favorite read: A Million Little Lies
Bibliophile UX Designer
Simon’s such a divisive character! On one hand, he’s orchestrating chaos from beyond the grave, which feels villainous. But on the other, you learn about his motives—how he felt invisible and wanted to expose the hypocrisy around him. It’s like he’s both the antagonist and a victim. The book cleverly uses his perspective (through his app posts) to make you grapple with that duality. I kept flipping between 'Okay, he’s awful' and 'Wait, but I get why he did it.' That moral complexity is what elevates the story beyond a typical whodunit. It’s less about labeling him and more about understanding how messed-up situations create messed-up actions.
2026-05-04 02:49:23
17
Bibliophile Consultant
Simon's role in 'One of Us Is Lying' is such a fascinating gray area! At first glance, yeah, he seems like the villain—he runs that gossip app, spills everyone's secrets, and then dies under suspicious circumstances, framing the main characters. But the more I thought about it, the more I wondered if he’s more of a tragic figure. His own secrets get revealed posthumously, and you realize he was just as trapped by the high school hierarchy as everyone else. The book does this brilliant job of making you question who the real antagonist is—is it Simon, or the system that pushed him to act out?

Honestly, I spent half the novel hating him and the other half pitying him. Karen M. McManus really nails that 'every villain is the hero of their own story' vibe. By the end, I wasn’t sure if Simon was the villain or just a messed-up kid who took things too far. It’s one of those stories where the lines blur, and that’s what makes it so addictive.
2026-05-04 04:40:49
7
Delilah
Delilah
Longtime Reader Nurse
Simon’s definitely framed as the villain early on—his app’s ruthlessness, his manipulation, even his death feels like a final act of revenge. But the twist? He’s not the only bad guy. The real villain might be the secrets and lies festering in Bayview. Simon just held up a mirror to it. The book makes you wonder if he’s truly evil or just the one who dared to expose the rot. That’s what I love about it—no easy answers, just messy, human truths.
2026-05-04 06:13:54
13
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

who killed simon in one of us is lying

4 Answers2025-02-06 12:01:29
In "One of Us is Dead", a stirring novel, Simon is the creator of a high school gossip app but meets an untimely end. Many are suspected.Whereas in actuality, things are not so simple. And in this case, he took his own life from terminal depression made it look as if one of his class mates had killed him.With this breathtaking plot twist, the author impels us to think about our actions and how deep human despair can go.

Who plays Simon in One of Us Is Lying?

4 Answers2026-04-28 13:45:23
Man, Simon from 'One of Us Is Lying' was such a pivotal character, and Mark McKenna absolutely nailed the role! He brought this eerie, almost magnetic energy to Simon that made you hate him but also weirdly fascinated by him. McKenna's background in music (he's part of the band Milk.) definitely adds layers to his performances—you can tell he understands rhythm and tension. What's wild is how different Simon feels from McKenna's other roles, like in 'Sing Street' or 'Red Rock.' He's got this chameleon quality that makes Simon feel both calculated and unpredictably human. The way he delivered those biting monologues? Chills. I’ve rewatched just for his scenes—it’s that good.

How does Simon die in One of Us Is Lying?

4 Answers2026-04-28 04:18:17
I just finished binge-reading 'One of Us Is Lying' last week, and Simon's death hit me harder than I expected. The whole setup is so clever—five students walk into detention, but only four walk out. Simon, the school's notorious gossip blogger, collapses after drinking water laced with peanut oil. It's later revealed he had a severe peanut allergy. The mystery unfolds like a twisted game of Clue, but with way more teenage drama. What really got me was how the aftermath exposed everyone's secrets, proving Simon's blog wasn't just rumors. The way Karen McManus writes it makes you question every character. At first, I thought it was an accident, but the autopsy confirms murder. The tension between the 'Bayview Four'—Bronwyn, Addy, Nate, and Cooper—keeps you guessing. Simon's death isn't just a plot device; it forces them to confront their own lies. I stayed up way too late finishing it because I had to know who did it. That final twist? Chef's kiss.

What secrets did Simon know in One of Us Is Lying?

4 Answers2026-04-28 06:10:25
Oh, Simon's secrets in 'One of Us Is Lying' were like a ticking time bomb—each one meticulously chosen to unravel the lives of Bayview High's so-called 'perfect' students. His gossip app, About That, wasn't just for clout; it was a weapon. He knew Addy was cheating on Jake with TJ, had dirt on Cooper's hidden sexuality, and uncovered Nate's probation violations. But the juiciest? Bronwyn's academic scandal—she paid someone to take a test for her. Simon's whole vibe was 'I see you,' and he weaponized that knowledge ruthlessly. What fascinates me is how Karen M. McManus made Simon simultaneously terrifying and pitiable. His death turns him into this specter haunting the group, but flashbacks reveal his loneliness. He wasn't just a villain—he was a kid who felt invisible until he held secrets over others. The irony? His own secret—the truth about his suicide ideation—was the one thing he couldn't weaponize. It adds this tragic layer that makes the book more than just a whodunit.

Why did Simon create the gossip app in One of Us Is Lying?

4 Answers2026-04-28 21:18:44
Simon's creation of the gossip app in 'One of Us Is Lying' feels like a twisted power play masked as social commentary. At first glance, it seems like he just wanted to expose secrets—typical high school drama fuel. But digging deeper, it’s clear he craved control. The guy was ostracized, labeled the 'outsider,' and the app became his megaphone. He turned the tables on the very people who made him feel invisible. What’s chilling is how calculated it was. He didn’t just spill tea randomly; he curated chaos, targeting specific secrets that would unravel lives. It wasn’t about justice or even gossip—it was about forcing everyone to see the hypocrisy in their perfect facades. The irony? In trying to tear others down, he became the villain he probably thought he was fighting. Makes you wonder if he ever realized he was just replicating the cruelty he hated.

Does Simon appear in One of Us Is Lying season 2?

4 Answers2026-04-28 22:54:50
Man, 'One of Us Is Lying' was such a wild ride, especially with Simon's fate hanging over the first season. For those wondering about season 2—yeah, it’s complicated. Simon’s death was the catalyst for everything, but the show plays with flashbacks and memories a lot. He does pop up in those, almost like a ghost haunting the others. It’s eerie but adds so much tension. The way they weave his presence into the story without undermining his death is pretty clever. I binged the whole season in a weekend, and those moments hit hard. Honestly, if you’re expecting Simon to be alive somehow, you’ll be disappointed. But his influence is everywhere. The characters can’t escape him, and neither can the audience. It’s less about his physical appearance and more about how his secrets keep unraveling. The writers really leaned into that psychological aspect, which made season 2 just as gripping as the first.

Related Searches

Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status