I finished the 'Dark Imperium' trilogy a few weeks ago, and I'm still chewing on it. As a sci-fi fan first and a 40k lore nut second, I found it a bit of a mixed bag. The opening is pure spectacle – Guilliman's awakening, the sheer scale of the Indomitus Crusade – but it can get bogged down in political maneuvering that reads like a fictional history textbook. If you're here for bolter porn and warp-tainted horror, there are better Black Library books. But if you're fascinated by the sheer, crumbling bureaucracy of the Imperium and what it means for a 'living' primarch to return to that mess, it's got a compelling core.
Honestly, I almost gave up after the first hundred pages of 'Dark Imperium'. Guy Haley's prose isn't the most lyrical, and the pace drags when it focuses on the Plague Wars. But it pays off in moments of pure, grimdark clarity, like Guilliman realizing his father's empire is a theocratic nightmare he can't fix. That existential dread, the weight of leading a doomed civilization, is a sci-fi theme that really stuck with me. It's not a fun read, but it's a significant one for the setting's modern era.