Becky X Tobey Novels & Stories

The thing about crossovers is that they live in the niches. For a pairing that isn't a fandom's main event like Becky x Tobey, you're not going to find a dedicated archive. Your best hunting ground ends up being the big, general platforms where authors tag everything meticulously. I've had the best luck on AO3, hands down.

The search operators there are a lifesaver. You can filter for the 'WordGirl' fandom, then add a second fandom tag—'Marvel' or 'Percy Jackson' or whatever you're craving—and then look for the Becky/Tobey relationship tag. It surfaces stories that would be buried anywhere else. I found this one where they were rival teen geniuses at S.H.I.E.L.D. Academy, and it just clicked perfectly. You do have to wade through some stuff that's more focused on other characters, but the gems are there.

I'd steer clear of FF.net for this. Their tagging system is too rigid for a specific crossover pairing; it's like trying to find a needle in a haystack with oven mitts on.

Okay so this might sound super basic but I actually love the classic 'mutual pining while stuck on assignment' setup. The one where they're both reporters chasing the same story or sent to cover some event together and have to share a hotel room because of budget cuts. It's such a perfect vehicle for all that forced proximity and bickering that inevitably gives way to accidental intimacy—like one of them having a nightmare and the other one actually comforting them instead of just making a sarcastic remark. You get to keep their competitive edges sharp while letting the walls come down in these quiet moments that neither will acknowledge come morning. I've read a few where Tobey's the one who gets a panic attack after a close call and Becky, for all her 'I'm fine, everything's fine' bravado, is weirdly good at grounding him without making it a thing.

What makes it work for them specifically is how their careers are already this huge point of collision and tension; using that same space as the catalyst for closeness feels earned. The trope can drift into melodrama if you're not careful, but when it's handled with a light touch and the dialogue stays snappy, it absolutely sings for these two. Bonus points if the resolution involves them choosing to collaborate on something instead of trying to scoop each other, because that feels like the real character growth.

The AO3 tag for 'Tobey Maguire x Andrew Garfield' is where a lot of the Becky-centric fics end up if you use the character filter for 'Becky (Spider-Man)'. It's a weird little corner of the fandom but the activity is surprisingly steady. You'll see a lot of 'what if' scenarios set during the events of 'Spider-Man: No Way Home'.

Honestly, the main thing is to search by the relationship tag 'Becky/Original Male Character' and then filter for 'Tobey Maguire' as an additional character. The naming conventions aren't standardized, so you have to be a bit of an archeologist. I found a good one last week titled 'Through the Looking Glass' that was a sweet coffee shop AU, of all things.

It's niche, so don't expect a flood of results, but the writers who are into it are dedicated. Sort by kudos and give the top five a shot—that's usually enough to get you started and maybe find the authors who write more in that vein.